Professional Reflective Portfolio

Part A

Personal Philosophy – what makes an effective Teacher Librarian?

Effective Teacher Librarians (TL) work collaboratively within a school to ensure that they support the vision of the school community. TL’s are responsible for ensuring students are explicitly taught digital and information literacy and how to be responsible and safe online. A TL is proactive in their approach to curriculum and ICT changes and challenges, working with teachers in the delivery of programs which empower students and build 21st century skills. Effective TL’s create a collaborative learning environment where students feel safe to be creative and curious in their learning and ultimately become lifelong learners with a love of reading.

Part B

At the beginning of my Master of Teacher Librarianship journey, my blog post, The First Post, I shared my excitement and anxiety levels about what lay ahead of me in not only completing this course, but also my journey to becoming a working Teacher Librarian (TL) and what I hoped to become in the future. My thoughts were based on collaborating with Teacher Librarians during my time as a classroom teacher and how I had found these individuals ‘godsends’; at the time I was relieved to have extra assistance with a class. However, at the conclusion of this degree, I can now reflect on the dedication of the TL and the importance of the information literacy skills and knowledge the TL was providing to students during the lessons undertaken in the library.

 

Two of my favourite units completed as part of this degree have been the electives ETL402 and INF533. Both of these units opened my eyes to young adult literature and the importance of the TL to be proactive to the changes taking place within the youth literature market. The importance of the inclusion of high quality literature in the collection and promoting the use of literary activities to colleagues which meet the needs of 21st century learners while engaging and encouraging students to read were highlighted throughout these units.

 

Young people aren’t reading anymore…ps the Teacher Librarian can help.

 

One of the most resonating ideas from the literature regarding youth and reading was summed up in my blog post The Changing of the Book, where two recent articles contradict what is occuring in the children’s and young adult book market. I tend to agree with Khyiah Angel (as cited in Taylor, 2018), where she stated ‘that children are reading more, they are just reading differently’. It is important to understand these changes in students’ preferences for reading and be able to adjust our thinking of what is a book, how students read and how we can engage students with literature.

 

In my blog post Children’s Literature I spoke about my need to develop a greater understanding of children’s literature, while I noted some strategies I am currently using to increase my exposure and knowledge of children’s literature. Through the completion of the two units I was able to further develop my understanding of children’s literature, especially various fiction genres. Also, how I can promote children’s literature through collaborating with classroom teachers and assisting in incorporating fiction into literary activities across a variety of curriculum units. Graphic novels are a genre of fiction which is often overlooked by educators as being a valuable teaching aid as they are considered to be a form of comic book. However, graphic novels have been gaining popularity with young adult readers since the late twentieth century and are now seen as an important inclusion in educational settings (Babee, 2017, p.1; Botzakis, 2018, p.140). Including graphic novels into a library collection provides students with the opportunity to engage with a popular genre, which is now a recommended text in the Australian Curriculum; importantly graphic novels can also be used as a multimodal teaching strategy across faculties. Through collaboration with our English faculty a number of traditional texts have now been purchased in the form of graphic novels; including The Handmaid’s Tale for Year 11 Advanced English and To Kill a Mockingbird for Year 10 English. Both graphic novels, while remaining true to the original story, improve comprehension of the novel and provide students with a greater appreciation and understanding of the key concepts and themes of the novels through visual representation (Chilton, 2018; Scott et al., 2017, p.127). The integration of graphic novels has allowed teachers to enhance the existing curriculum and build on students’ multimodal knowledge as required in the Australian Curriculum.

 

A number of graphic novels have been added to the library collection to assist in enhancing the existing curriculum.

 

Another avenue to engage and encourage students to read is through the use of audio and ebooks. The Association of American Publishers found that the audiobook market is the fastest growing publishing format, with audiobook sales increasing by over 40% in 2018 (Trombetta, 2019; Poole, 2019; Catalano, 2018), and the global market expected to grow by another 25% in 2020 (Thorp, 2020). Audiobooks are becoming increasingly popular in educational settings as digital literacy helps to engage and assist students. Using audiobooks assists students who are experiencing difficulties with reading as they are able to utilise the functionality of digitized works. Through using digitised works students can slow down the narration of audiobooks as well as increase the font size of ebooks. Increasing the font size on screen leads to greater space between letters and lines and ultimately leads to a more immersive and improved reading experience (DeLamater, 2010; Anguera, 2015), this can assist students who have dyslexia or experience reading difficulties. While listening to books can benefit students’ literacy through hearing pronunciation and intonation, as well as increasing the students’ exposure to words. Through developing my knowledge and understanding of the benefits of digitised works I was able to advocate the continued inclusion of audio and ebooks as part of the collection of our school library. I reflected on the importance of a virtual library as an addition to the library collection when completing ETL 503, having access to the virtual library assists in eliminating geographical and access constraints when students require resources; the virtual library has been especially beneficial this year due to COVID-19 lockdowns and restrictions students faced accessing physical reading materials. The virtual library has also been welcomed by teachers and used extensively with students with low literacy or learning difficulties.

 

Opening the doors to ICT – In the library, can this happen?

 

A key goal for our school was to increase access to technology and ensure students developed 21st century ICT skills. I was able to successfully gain funding to set up a dedicated bank of laptops in what was an underutilised room in the library during 2018; since that time, technology in the library has exponentially grown, allowing a large number of classes the opportunity to use technology throughout the day. Ensuring students are undertaking meaningful technology lessons which meet curriculum requirements, digital citizenship requirements and student engagement was a secondary goal of the school. Teachers at the school commented on their lack of confidence and knowledge surrounding technology, digital citizenship and how they could implement technology into their lesson plans (D. Pilja, personal communication, May 18, 2019; J. Dasic, personal communication, May 18, 2019).

 

Through my role as TL I was able to assist teachers with technology based lesson plans and activities. As stated in my critical reflection new technology is being created and used at a phenomenal rate, with students often the first to engage and use new technology as it becomes available. It is imperative that we, as educators, stay abreast of these technological and social changes in order to keep students motivated and to learn essential information and communication technology skills, as highlighted in the Australian Curriculum, while they are engaging with technology. The use and creation of digital stories is one strategy to do this. The digital story  Reginald James Charles – An Australian War Hero, while an assessment requirement for INF533, has been used within our school as an example for Stage 4 students to create their own digital texts. This enrichment activity proved to be very successful with high engagement from students; the students developed knowledge and understanding of 21st century ICT skills while embedding digital literacy skills and citizenship in the creation of their final product. Through collaborating with the classroom teacher I was also able to provide professional development and dialogue on the affordances of effectively using technology in the classroom to meet learning outcomes. Feedback from colleagues has shown they are now less apprehensive to use technology in their classes and have a greater understanding of digital citizenship (M. Walker, personal communication, March 23, 2020; A. Fenech, personal communication, May 13, 2020). The digital story has also been used by our Defence Mentor with the wider military community, her feedback has been that it is an important and relevant advocacy tool for our school (T. Carr, April 28, 2020).

 

Another literary activity which I was exposed to through ETL402 was book bento boxes. I used the concept of book bentos as a book week competition for students and staff to enter. Students and staff were able to create their bento for a book they were currently reading or their favourite book. I find book bentos an excellent learning experience to reflect on their reading while also developing 21st century skills. The benefit of book bentos as a multimodal strategy is that students are also being explicitly provided information regarding copyright and the ethical use of music, pictures and book covers; students are encouraged to use Creative Commons to access media and are shown the correct way to acknowledge sources they use to create their book bento. I have already planned collaboratively with our HSIE faculty to implement the literary learning program I created for assignment two of ETL402, with our Year 10 cohort when they are completing the depth study Rights and Freedoms 1945-present (Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority, 2010) in term four.

 

I have also been heavily involved with technology within the school as a whole. The Stem.4L kits borrowed through the Department of Education have been very successful with students. The kits have been used with specialist teaching areas and also whole year groups in the school being provided with the ability to experience virtual reality, robotics and film making. I am also a member of the school’s technology team and this year the team is trialing student devices. One class in year 7 and 8 are trialing Apple Ipads versus Google Chromebooks in order to discover the benefits for student participation and engagement with technology as well as the best device for student use. Based on the outcomes of the trial it is hoped that the year 7 cohort for 2021 will be lent a student device for school use for the year.

Stem.4L kits in action.

 

Making the library an essential learning common in the school – Advocacy in action.

 

I was lucky enough to obtain a temporary TL position in a school, the library had been traditionally managed by the previous TL, who had a long standing position at the school. The library was cold, uninviting, devoid of life and a little smelly; there was a closed door policy for certain periods of the day and silence was required at all times.

 

Through completing ETL402 and ETL503 I was able to begin to develop my understanding of the importance of an information professional in schools. In my blog posts The Perceptions of Librarians and Reflections I reflected on the evolving and ever changing role of the TL and how I could advocate my role in the school. I started reading, and continue to read, articles about how TL’s can be change agents within schools, the importance of school libraries and strategies TL’s can use to successfully manage and promote their role and the library.

 

From the knowledge gained in ETL503 I saw the importance of collaborating with staff to develop a working collections development policy, I sought out individuals in each faculty to speak with to ensure the policy would meet the curriculum needs of the school. I also asked students to provide their feedback on the library, resources they would like available to them in the library and books they enjoyed reading. I undertook surveys with students to gain a better understanding of the reading habits of the student community. This allowed me to develop a better understanding of the recreational reading needs of the students and the areas of the collection which were lacking. I found through writing the collection development policy I had a greater understanding of the school community I was working with and the areas of the collection which needed improvement. The policy assisted in decluttering the collection; a large number of especially nonfiction resources were outdated and no longer relevant to the learning needs of the school.

 

I started to look for activities and resources that could be used to promote the library and get students and staff engaged and excited about the library. I joined a number of professional TL groups including Yammer, NSW School Library Matters, and The School Librarians Workshop on Facebook as well as a number of Instagram accounts that are strong advocates for libraries such as misskokolib and icentremta.

 

A number of key activities were promoted specifically to staff in an attempt to encourage staff to utilise my services and the library. A Library Lovers gift bag was made for all staff and secretly dropped on their desks on Library Lovers Day. The gift bags included items to promote what the library had to offer as well as how I, as the information specialist of the school, can assist teachers in planning, developing and implementing lessons and programs; the bags also included a number of small gifts to bring joy to the day. Book Week was another opportunity to promote the library and the importance of reading to students and staff. With the assistance of some key staff members a whole staff book character dress up day and staff and student lunch was organised. The day was an outstanding success and led to a heightened profile of the library as key changes were promoted during the lunch and book talk took place between students and staff.

Advocacy in action.

 

Utilising Facebook, Instagram and the school’s regular newsletter to promote activities taking place within the library allowed for greater connection and communication with the school and wider community. I found a number of key guides to assist with social media promotions including The National Library of New Zealand, Softlink and a number of relevant articles from SCIS Connections. During my professional placement I was also able to take part in a public libraries marketing team meeting via Zoom; I found this an invaluable experience as reflected in my placement report as it provided further insight into the use of social media by informational specialists.

 

 

 

Part C

Personal evaluation.

 

As I reach the end of the Master of Teacher Librarianship degree it is important to reflect on the journey and see just how far I have come. It is important to also consider the future, as I embark on the challenges of Teacher Librarianship in a high school setting, as well as considering further career opportunities which the degree can provide with ongoing learning. The standards of professional excellence for Teacher Librarians is an invaluable tool for not only reflecting on my current professional knowledge and practice; but can also serve as a goal setting tool to assist in my continued professional learning and development to improve my professional practice and ultimately become a successful teacher librarian.

 

Throughout the course I have realised the importance of staying abreast of changes in curriculum and technology and ensuring that I am proactive in my approach to cross curricula library programs, with a technology focus. 21st century skills are embedded throughout the Australian Curriculum; it is one of the many essential roles of the TL to ensure they assist their colleagues in implementing technology usage, as well as equipping students with the skills to appropriately use ICT and information resources (1.1;2.2). I am now more confident to work with colleagues to explicitly teach students about the ethical use of media and copyright, through the use of sites such as Creative Commons. I am also equipped to teach the digital literacy skills required to find, evaluate and compose digital information and to correctly acknowledge sources, this will ultimately assist students to be responsible digital citizens throughout their schooling, further education and careers (State of NSW, 2020).

 

Creating a space where 21st century skills can be explicitly taught and practiced is also an essential requirement of current school libraries. School libraries are evolving to become places of significance within schools as they take on the dual role of literary and technological spaces (2.1). Ensuring the library space is well resourced and meets the needs of the school community is a challenging aspect of the role of the TL. Through my growing understanding of the needs of the various stakeholders of the school, I will strive to ensure the library is effectively meeting the diverse needs of our school community.

 

Advocating the role of TL’s and essential services that can be provided by the library are key personal goals I have for the future. Greater promotion of the opportunities I can provide to staff in their teaching and professional development is also important to me in my role as TL. I am looking forward to having the time to read a greater range of young adult books from various genres and creating a strong reading culture within the school community. Joining professional associations & network groups will also assist in my professional development and provide further ideas on how to future proof the school library and ensure that I am pivotal in meeting the vision of the school.

 

 

 

 

 

 

References.

 

 

Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority. (2010). Year 10 content descriptions. https://www.australiancurriculum.edu.au/f-10-curriculum/humanities-and-social-sciences/history/

 

Australian Library and Information Association. (2004). Standards of professional excellence for teacher librarians. https://www.alia.org.au/about-alia/policies-standards-and-guidelines/standards-professional-excellence-teacher-librarians

 

Babaee, R. (2017). Realities of Graphic Novels: An Interview with Frederick Aldama. International Journal of Comparative Literature and Translation Studies, 5(3), 1-4. doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.7575/aiac.ijclts.v.5n.3p.1

 

Botzakis, S. (2018). Comics in the Classroom. In Wooten, D. A., Liang, L. A., & Cullinan, B. E. (Eds.). Children’s literature in the reading program, fifth edition: Engaging young readers in the 21st century. 140-152. https://ebookcentral.proquest.com

 

Catalano, F. (2018, August 11). Listen up: Digital audiobooks now the ‘fastest growing format’ as tech and titles improve. GeekWire. https://www.geekwire.com/2018/listen-digital-audiobooks-now-fastest-growing-format-tech-titles-improve/

 

Dunn, B. (2017, July 20). The first post. [Blog post]. https://thinkspace.csu.edu.au/bellid/2017/07/20/the-first-post/

 

Dunn, B. (2020, March 6). The changing of the book. [Blog post]. https://thinkspace.csu.edu.au/bellid/2020/03/06/the-changing-of-the-book/

 

Dunn, B. (2020, March 20). Children’s literature. [Blog post]. https://thinkspace.csu.edu.au/bellid/2020/03/20/childrens-literature/

 

 

Dunn, B. (2019, May 27). Reflections. [Blog post]. https://thinkspace.csu.edu.au/bellid/2019/05/27/etl-503-reflections/

 

Dunn, B. (2019, October 5). INF533 Critical reflection. [Blog post]. https://thinkspace.csu.edu.au/bellid/2019/10/05/inf533-assessment-4-part-c-700-words/

 

Dunn, B. (2017, July 13). The perceptions of librarians. [Blog post]. https://thinkspace.csu.edu.au/bellid/2017/07/23/the-perception-of-librarians/

 

Dunn, B. (2020, September 9). Professional placement report. [Blog post]. https://thinkspace.csu.edu.au/bellid/2020/09/09/professional-placement-report/

 

Poole, S. (2019, July 13). Listen up: why we can’t get enough of audiobooks. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/books/2019/jul/13/listen-up-rise-of-audiobooks-steven-poole

 

Softlink. (2020). Social media ideas for the school library. https://www.softlinkint.com/blog/social-media-rise-your-school-library/

 

State of New South Wales [Department of Education]. (2020). Copyright and creative commons. https://www.digitalcitizenship.nsw.edu.au/articles/copyright-and-creative-commons

 

Stower, H., & Donaghue, M. (2016). Using social media to support school library services. School Catalogue Information Service. https://www.scisdata.com/connections/issue-98/using-social-media-to-support-school-library-services/

 

Taylor, A. (2018, September 16). ‘Technology can bring books alive’: Harry Potter inspires novel with moving images. The Sydney Morning Herald. https://www.smh.com.au/entertainment/books/technology-can-bring-books-alive-harry-potter-inspires-novel-with-moving-images-20180915-p50407.html

 

The National Library of New Zealand. (n.d.). Social media and the school library. https://natlib.govt.nz/schools/school-libraries/library-services-for-teaching-and-learning/your-school-library-online/social-media-and-the-school-library

 

Thorp, C. (2020, January 6). Audiobooks: The rise and rise of the books you don’t read. BBC. https://www.bbc.com/culture/article/20200104-audiobooks-the-rise-and-rise-of-the-books-you-dont-read

 

Trombetta, S. (2019, May 24). There’s actually a scientific reason for why you love audiobooks so much. Bustle. https://www.bustle.com/p/why-audiobook-listening-is-growing-in-popularity-with-readers-17186269

Posted in ETL 507 | Tagged | Leave a comment

Research Proposal

 

 

Table of Contents

 

Identification of Topic. 2

Literature Review.. 4

Benefits of audiobooks for English as an Additional Language or Dialect students  4

Benefits of audiobooks for students with learning difficulties/disabilities. 5

Gaps and Research Question. 6

Theoretical perspective and methodology. 6

Proposed study design. 7

Description of research methodology. 7

Advantages and disadvantages associated with the data gathering. 8

Description of the sampling procedures. 9

Analysis of data. 9

Ethical Considerations. 10

Harm to participants. 10

Informed consent 10

Privacy of participants. 11

Deceptive practices. 11

References. 12

Appendix A.. 18

Self-Completion Questionnaires. 18

Appendix B.. 19

Statistical analysis of information gathered through the Accelerated Reading program   19

Appendix C.. 20

Minimal Risk Review Checklist 21

Information for Research Participants. 29

Consent Form.. 30

 

Identification of Topic

 

Audiobooks are becoming increasingly popular in the education setting, as they have been shown to benefit students’ literacy through listening to pronunciation and intonation as well as increasing the students’ exposure to words. Studies have also found that listeners are more emotionally engaged with audiobooks when compared to watching television or movies (Trombetta, 2019; Catalano, 2018; Esteves & Whitten, 2011). Audiobooks also provide the listener with the opportunity to change the speed of narration, further enhancing students with lowered literacy the opportunity to better understand and comprehend the storyline. Audiobooks are an exact replica of the printed material; growing sales and increased demand for audiobooks have led to the production of audiobooks becoming more creative and ambitious with popular actors often employed to narrate the stories.

 

Students with learning difficulties/disabilities or have English as an Additional Language or Dialect (EAL/D) often experience difficulties in comprehending text when reading traditional print material. This often results in poor reading skill development, which consequently leads to negative attitudes to reading and ultimately decreased academic achievement in the school setting (Tusmagambet, 2020).  Lamb (2011, p. 16), Johnson (2009, p. 105) and Labbo (2000, p. 543) describe the benefits of audiobooks to students through differentiating instruction – audiobooks can offer more time for reading, lead to independent reading, serve as a model of verbal fluency, motivate reluctant readers, and improve the English vocabulary development of EAL/D students; these benefits ultimately lead to greater educational outcomes for students.

 

Original research has not taken place in the Australian context to show the benefits of audiobooks on reading comprehension and motivation. There is also an underrepresentation of research based in educational settings for students aged 12-16 years and over a research period greater than eight weeks. The proposed research question will address the advanced gaps in the Australian education context for the benefits of audiobooks for students with learning disabilities or EAL/D backgrounds. This will be presented at the end of the literature review.

 

 

Table 1: Definitions of key terms

 

Term Definition
Accelerated Reader A program used in the school to assess students’ reading age. The program delivers powerful insight into students’ literacy growth. The program allows students to undertake quizzes on books they have read to gain an understanding of their comprehension and engagement with books (Renaissance Learning, 2019).
Audiobook Audiobooks are described as a digitized work.
DEAR Drop Everything And Read.

A structured reading program for students in years 7-10 which takes place for 20 minutes at the beginning of each day.

Digitised Work Digitized works are defined as a work conceived for another medium, such as the printed medium (Bouchard & Heckmann, 2012).
NAPLAN The National Assessment Program – Literacy and Numeracy (NAPLAN) is a snapshot of how students are progressing against national standards in literacy and numeracy over time (Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority [ACARA], 2011).
NAPLAN Assessment Scale For NAPLAN results a national minimum standard is defined and located on the assessment scale for each year level. Band 3 represents students performing below the national minimum standard in Year 5. While Band 4 represents students performing below the national minimum standard in Year 7 (Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority [ACARA], 2011).
Reading Comprehension The ability to understand a text, to analyse and interpret information from the text (Elleman & Oslund, 2019).

 

 

 

Literature Review

 

Reading benefits students’ cognitive development and academic success (Moore & Cahill, 2016), which ultimately leads to student engagement and remaining at school to complete their studies. For students with learning difficulties, disabilities or an EAL/D background the ability to read and comprehend what they are reading is diminished.  Recent research related to the use of audiobooks to assist student’s development and engagement are reviewed below.

 

Benefits of audiobooks for English as an Additional Language or Dialect students

 

Meta-analysis studies completed in America and Spain (Moore & Cahill, 2016; Alcantud-Diaz & Gregori-Signes, 2014) found that students’ reading comprehension, spoken interaction and writing improved with the use of audiobooks. Similarly, a mixed method study; involving quantitative data from comprehension skills testing and qualitative data from participants’ opinions about the use of audiobooks (Bryman, 2016, p. 193-194; Creswell, 2012, p.22)  was undertaken in Turkey with 66 first year university students; aged 18-22 (Kartal & Simsek, 2017). Quantitative results from this study showed significantly higher comprehension skills post trial, whilst qualitative results in this trial showed students believed the audiobooks improved their reading and listening comprehension. Research undertaken in Taiwan (Chang & Millett, 2015) and Spain (Tragant Mestres, Llanes Baró, & Pinyana Garriga 2018) with significantly reasonable sample sizes (Wilson Van Voorhis & Morgan, 2007 p. 48); 64 year 10 secondary students and 100 upper primary school students respectively, found significant differences between silent reading and audiobook reading for reading rates and comprehension through the use of ANOVA test measures (Lewis-Beck, Bryman & Futing, 2004, p. 657). The Taiwanese results in particular found a large effect size on improving reading rates, comprehension and enjoyment with using audiobooks. Conversely, the Spanish study did not report significant improvements in quantitative results; this may have been a result of a short intervention period and the technology and/or reading material used for the research. However, qualitative results related to engagement were significant.

 

All reviewed studies undertaken with EAL/D students took places in countries with non-English speaking backgrounds learning English, the Kartal and Simsek (2017) research with an age range of 18-22, leads to issues of translatability of profiles to the Australian education context and limits generalisabilty to our school system (McMillan & Wergin, 2010, p. 12-13). Other weaknesses of the reviewed research include the length of study periods (Tragant Mestres, Llanes Baró & Pinyana Garriga, 2018) and rapid changes in the production and delivery of audiobooks relative to the age of research articles.

 

Benefits of audiobooks for students with learning difficulties/disabilities

 

Meta-analysis research (Moore & Cahill, 2016; Stevens, Walker & Vaughan, 2014; Ness & Berry, 2013) showed some positive outcomes, including greater independence and accessibility for students with learning difficulties, as well as improved motivation to reading and some comprehension development (Moore & Cahill, 2016)  when students used audiobooks. Similarly, positive improvements in accessibility, reading comprehension, fluency and attitudes to reading were attributed to audiobooks in a number of studies using various research methods (Whittingham, Huffman, Christensen & McAllister, 2013; Esteves & Whitten, 2011; Davies, Stock, King & Wehmeyer, 2008; Boyle, Rosenberg, Connelly, Washburn, Brinckerhoff & Banerjee, 2003).

 

Rapid changes in the production and delivery of audiobooks relative to the age of the research projects must be taken into account when considering these research papers. Small sample sizes (Whittingham, Huffman, Christensen & McAllister, 2013; Esteves & Whitten, 2011; Davies, Stock, King & Wehmeyer, 2008) and short treatment durations, 6-8 weeks (Boyle, Rosenberg, Connelly, Washburn, Brinckerhoff & Banerjee, 2003; Davies, Stock, King & Wehmeyer, 2008), along with age of participants higher than school age (Davies, Stock, King & Wehmeyer, 2008) and the localisation of the research to America, all limit the generalisabilty of the research to the Australian school setting.

 

Gaps and Research Question

 

The literature review highlights a number of significant gaps in the research:

  • No research has been undertaken in Australian high school settings.
  • Relative age of previous research is high, given the development and attitudes to technology, ultimately influencing students’ access and engagement with audiobooks.
  • Testing time frames are relatively small, 6-8 weeks, making validity of research difficult.
  • Age of participants in previous studies limits generalisability.

As such the following research question is proposed:

Does a long term, ten week, audiobook program at a SW Sydney high school covary with improved reading comprehension test scores and engagement with reading for students with learning difficulties/disabilities or EALD backgrounds?

 

 

Theoretical perspective and methodology

 

In order to address the limitations outlined above and to further build upon the existing literature related to the benefits of audiobooks for students with learning difficulties/disabilities or EAL/D backgrounds, the researcher will apply a philosophical orientation toward the pragmatist approach, this will allow the research to take place in a flexible and objective manner using both qualitative and quantitative approaches to answer the research question (Onwuegbuzie & Leech, 2005). A pragmatist approach has been chosen over a purely epistemological or ontological approach as it will allow the benefits of both approaches to be adapted for the research. Through using a mixed methods approach for the research, the strengths of both qualitative and quantitative data collection and analysis can be incorporated (Tashakkori & Creswell, 2007). While Bryman (2016) recognises there has been a long held divide between qualitative and quantitative researchers, Punch (2005) and Creswell (2012) highlight that using mixed methods approaches ultimately increases the scope and robustness of the research. A mixed methods approach represents an interactive continuum and will lead to a more complete understanding of the benefits of audiobooks to improve literacy test scores and engagement with reading for students with learning difficulties/disabilities or EALD backgrounds. A mixed methods approach is seen as more desirable than a purely quantitative study, as it will allow the development of an understanding into how audiobooks benefit students’ engagement and motivation to read. The mixed methods approach will also lead to a conceptual framework being developed which will validate quantitative findings by referring to information from the qualitative phase of the study, and using the qualitative data to analyse information gathered from the quantitative data (Onwuegbuzie & Leech, 2005). This will lead to a deeper analysis of the research question through triangulation of results and, ultimately, more robust research findings; with a greater understanding of the benefits of audiobooks for engagement as well as an understanding of improvements in student’s literacy due to the use of audiobooks.

 

 

Proposed study design

 

Description of research methodology

 

The research methods refer to the way in which data will be collected for the study (Bryman, 2016). The research will take place with students in Years 7 and 8 at one government high school, due to limited funds, time and staffing. Students who have identified learning difficulties/disabilities or are from an EAL/D background and have achieved below the national minimum standard for literacy; Band 3 in Year 5 and/or Band 4 in Year 7 will be included in the research. There will be 60 students invited to participate in the research, with an approximate non-participation rate of 10%; this should lead to approximately 54 students across the two year levels being involved in the research. Students will be randomly placed into two groups; this will allow for one group to undertake reading with audiobooks, while the other group will act as a control group and continue reading with traditional material. To overcome fairness issues students from the control and treatment groups will be swapped to provide all students with equal access to the trial material over ten week time frames.

 

Students will undertake a pre and post self-completion questionnaires, which focus on their current reading habits, enjoyment and motivation to read, as well as their exposure to audiobooks (Appendix A). Students will also be assessed using the Accelerated Reading program (Renaissance Learning, 2019), to gain an understanding of their current reading age and reading comprehension. The program will also be used throughout the research period to measure their comprehension of books they have listened to/read and at the end of the trial period to gain an understanding of any improvements in their reading comprehension test scores and reading age.

 

Students in the research group will attend their scheduled DEAR time in the school library each morning. The Teacher Librarian and School Learning Support Officers will assist students with their selection of audiobooks and completion of Accelerated Reading testing as the students finish each book. The library provides an area with access to staff, technology and a calm environment, where students can engage with the reading material and readily undertake comprehension testing as they finish books targeted to their interests and skill level.

 

Advantages and disadvantages associated with the data gathering

 

One of the major limiting factors of the research is that it is only taking place in one government high school. Due to accessibility, convenience sampling will occur for this research project, this may limit generalisability (Bryman, 2016). However it is hoped that, while the data may not generate definitive findings, that the research may be used for larger studies across school communities within the South West Sydney Network in the future if results are positive (Bryman, 2016).

 

The use of self-administered questionnaires as part of the research process has the advantages of cost effectiveness, less interviewer bias, decreased variability in implementation, reduced administration time and greater convenience for participants (Bryman, 2016). While disadvantages include a greater risk of missing additional data, the inability to probe respondents for further elaboration in their answering of the questions and students having to read the questions themselves, which may reduce data quantity and quality in answers (Bryman, 2016).

 

The use of the Accelerated Reading program is advantageous, as it collects and analyses the data on reading comprehension, it is also convenient for the researcher as it is already used within the school and students and staff are familiar with the use of the program. However, the use of the program may make generalisability difficult as not all schools use the program.

 

Description of the sampling procedures

 

A single school sample of convenience population will be used for the research due to accessibility; while this may be seen to limit generalisability (Bryman, 2016), as discussed above, it is hoped that the research will be used for larger research in the future. Some elements of purposive research will also take place as students for the research are being selected based on criterion and critical case sampling (Bryman, 2016). Criterion based sampling is taking place, as students are being selected based on their current national minimum standard being below the national average for literacy and/or the students have an EAL/D background. Critical case sampling is occurring as it is believed that the theory of using audiobooks for students with learning disabilities/difficulties or EAL/D backgrounds will benefit their reading comprehension and engagement with reading.

 

Analysis of data

 

Statistical and thematic analysis of data will take place in order to answer the research question. Statistical analysis of information gathered through the Accelerated Reading program will provide an understanding of how students’ reading comprehension and reading age may have been positively influenced during the audiobook trial; an example of the data analysis is shown in Appendix B. Statistical analysis of the quantitative questions in the pre and post self-questionnaires will also take place to see if students’ thoughts on reading and use of audiobooks has changed.

 

A thematic analysis of the qualitative questions from the pre and post self-questionnaires will be undertaken. Coding will take place to assist in making sense of the data and to identify core themes that emerge from the data; this will ultimately assist in managing and understanding the qualitative data which has been collected (Bryman, 2016).

 

 

Ethical Considerations

 

As highlighted by Diener and Crandall (1978, as cited in Bryman, 2016, p. 125) and Gray (2018, p. 75) the ethical considerations for research; especially for research undertaken in an educational setting, fall into four main areas of concern: harm to participants, informed consent of participants, privacy of participants and avoiding deception in the research process. While these ethical considerations are often considered universal it is important to outline how the research study will meet each of the considerations in order to ensure that there is minimal risk to participants and to assert that no participants will be worse off from taking part in the research process.

 

Harm to participants

 

Within a high school setting it is important to minimise the risk of harm to participants. Whilst it is unlikely that physical harm will occur due to this research there may be increased risk of psychological or social harm associated with taking part in the research, which may lead to undue stress, social stigmatisation and loss of self-esteem (Bryman, 2016, p. 126; New South Wales Department of Education, 2019, p. 7; University of Virginia, 2020). Bryman (2016, p. 127) also states that ethical codes, such as those set out in the State of New South Wales Department of Education (2020a) code of conduct, advocate care over managing and protecting the confidentiality of information and record keeping. As such the information gathered during the research process will be confidential and securely held within a locked cabinet in the library office as outlined in the Records Management Program (State of New South Wales Department of Education, 2020b), all records will be shredded and disposed of within a five year time period from the completion of the research. It is believed that this research project, through the use of anomyality and sensitivity of record keeping will present minimal harm to participants.

 

Informed consent

 

Organisational consent to undertake this research project (Gray, 2018, p. 76) must firstly be gained through the NSW State Education Research Applications Process (State of New South Wales Department of Education, 2020c) and Charles Sturt University, prior to approaching individuals to take part in the research. Once organisational consent has been approved it is essential that participants are provided with detailed information regarding their participation in the research project in order for them to make an informed decision about taking part in the research (Bryman, 2016, p.129; Gray, 2018, p. 76). This is especially important for individuals who are considered vulnerable, as in this case school students, who may have special educational needs or come from vulnerable backgrounds such as refugees (Gray, 2018, p. 77). Information will be provided to students and parent/guardians that is meaningful, succinct and timely (Gray, 2018) in the form of a letter, which must be signed by the student and their legal guardian outlining the project (Appendix C), to ensure that any questions in regard to participating in the research can be answered and the opportunity to not be involved is made available.

 

Privacy of participants

 

To minimise invasion of privacy, participants will each have a unique anonymous code to identify their data in order to meet confidentiality of data collection (Bryman, 2016, p. 133; Gray, 2018, p.79). The researchers will have access to documents relating to participants’ names and codes. These records will be destroyed at the conclusion of the research process. It will also be made clear to participants that they have the right to withdraw from the research at any time and that their participation is voluntary.

 

Deceptive practices

 

Ensuring the transparency of the research process, the State of New South Wales Department of Education (2020a) code of conduct and informed consent documents (Appendix C) deceptive practices will not be a concern for this research project.

 

References

Alcantud-Diaz, M. and Gregori-Signes, C. (2013). Audiobooks: improving fluency and instilling literary skills and education for development. Directory of open access journals, 20(1), pp.111-125. https://doaj.org/article/40c57792d3c643d09282d7651f3adcab

Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority [ACARA]. (2011). National assessment program. https://www.nap.edu.au/results-and-reports/how-to-interpret#:~:text=For%20NAPLAN%20results%2C%20a%20national,minimum%20standard%20for%20Year%209.

 

Bryman, A. (2016). Social research methods (5th ed.). Oxford University Press.

Bourchardon, S. & Heckman, D. (2012). Digital manipulability and digital literature. Electronic Book Review. http://www.electronicbookreview.com/thread/electropoetics/heuristic

Boyle, E. A., Rosenberg, M. S., Connelly, V. J., Washburn, S. G., Brinckerhoff, L. C., & Banerjee, M. (2003). Effects of Audio Texts on the Acquisition of Secondary-Level Content by Students with Mild Disabilities. Learning Disability Quarterly, 26(3), 203–214. https://doi-org.ezproxy.csu.edu.au/10.2307/1593652

Catalano, F. (2018, August 11). Listen up: Digital audiobooks now the ‘fastest growing format’ as tech and titles improve. GeekWire. https://www.geekwire.com/2018/listen-digital-audiobooks-now-fastest-growing-format-tech-titles-improve/

Chang, A., & Millett, S. (2015). Improving reading rates and comprehension through audio-assisted extensive reading for beginner learners. System, 52, 91-102. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.system.2015.05.003

Creswell, J. (2012). The process of conducting research using quantitative and qualitative approaches. In Educational research: planning, conducting and evaluating quantitative and qualitative research (4th ed.) (pp. 8-24). Pearson.

Davies, D., Stock, S., King, L., & Wehmeyer, M. (2008). “Moby-Dick Is My Favorite:” Evaluating a Cognitively Accessible Portable Reading System for Audiobooks for Individuals With Intellectual Disability. Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities, 46(4), 290-298. https://doi.org/10.1352/1934-9556(2008)46[290:mimfea]2.0.co;2

Elleman, A. M., & Oslund, E. L. (2019). Reading Comprehension Research: Implications for Practice and Policy. Policy Insights from the Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 6(1), 3–11. https://doi.org/10.1177/2372732218816339

Esteves, K. J., & Whitten, E. (2011). Assisted reading with digital audiobooks for students with reading disabilities. Reading Horizons, 51(1), 21-40. https://ezproxy.csu.edu.au/login?url=https://search-proquest-com.ezproxy.csu.edu.au/docview/873824877?accountid=10344

Gray, D. (2018). Research Ethics. Doing research in the real world (4th ed.) SAGE Publications.

Johnson, P. (2009). Fundamentals of Collection Development and Management (Vol. 2nd ed). Chicago: ALA Editions.

Kartal, G., & Simsek, H. (2017). The effects of audiobooks on EFL students’ listening comprehension. The Reading Matrix: An International Online Journal, 17(1), 112-123.

Labbo, L. (2000). 12 Things Young Children Can Do with a Talking Book in a Classroom Computer Center. The Reading Teacher, 53(7), 542-546. www.jstor.org/stable/20204838

Lamb, A. (2011). Reading redefined for a transmedia universe. Learning and leading with technology, 39(3), 12-17. http://ezproxy.csu.edu.au/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/ login.aspx?direct=true&db=ehh&AN=67371172&site=ehost-live

Lewis-Beck, M. S., Bryman, A., & Futing Liao, T. (2004). The SAGE encyclopedia of social science research methods (Vols. 1-0). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, Inc. doi: 10.4135/9781412950589

McMillan, J. H. & Wergin, J. F. (2010). Introduction to reading educational research. Understanding and evaluating educational research (4th ed.). Pearson/Merrill.

Moore, J. and Cahill, M. (2016). Audiobooks: Legitimate “Reading” Material for Adolescents? Research Journal of the American Association of School Libraries, 19. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1120838.pdf

Nees, M., & Berry, L. (2013). Audio assistive technology and accommodations for students with visual impairments: Potentials and problems for delivering curricula and educational assessments. Performance Enhancement & Health, 2(3), 101-109. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.peh.2013.08.016

NSW Department of Education. (2019). State education research applications process. Guidelines 2019. https://app.education.nsw.gov.au/serap/Content/resources/SERAP%20Guidelines.pdf

Onwuegbuzie, A., & Leech, N. (2005). On Becoming a Pragmatic Researcher: The Importance of Combining Quantitative and Qualitative Research Methodologies. International Journal of Social Research Methodology, 8(5), 375-387. https://doi.org/10.1080/13645570500402447

Punch, K. (2005). Extract from Mixed methods and evaluation. Introduction to social research: quantitative and qualitative approaches (2nd ed.) 306-309. Sage.

Renaissance Learning. (2019). Accelerated reader. https://p.widencdn.net/qlkjez/283675-AR-Gatefold-Brochure_final

State of New South Wales Department of Education. (2020a). Enterprise data policy https://policies.education.nsw.gov.au/policy-library/policies/enterprise-data-policy?refid=285851

State of New South Wales Department of Education. (2020b).Records management program https://policies.education.nsw.gov.au/policy-library/policies/records-management-program?refid=285851

 

State of New South Wales Department of Education. (2020c). NSW state education research applications process. https://app.education.nsw.gov.au/serap/

Tashakkori, A., & Creswell, J. (2007). The new era of mixed methods. Journal of mixed methods research. doi: 10.1177/2345678906293042

Tragant Mestres, E., Llanes Baró, À., & Pinyana Garriga, À. (2018). Linguistic and non-linguistic outcomes of a reading-while-listening program for young learners of English.  Reading and Writing, 32(3), 819-838. doi:http://dx.doi.org.ezproxy.csu.edu.au/10.1007/s11145-018-9886-x

Trombetta, S. (2019, May 24). There’s actually a scientific reason for why you love audiobooks so much. Bustle. https://www.bustle.com/p/why-audiobook-listening-is-growing-in-popularity-with-readers-17186269

Tusmagambet, B. (2020). Effects of Audiobooks on EFL Learners’ Reading Development: Focus on Fluency and Motivation. English Teaching, 75(2), 41–67. https://doi-org.ezproxy.csu.edu.au/10.15858/engtea.75.2.202006.41

 

University of Virginia. (2020). Types of harm. https://research.virginia.edu/types-harm

Wallace, M., & Wray, A. (2006). Extracts. In Critical reading and writing for postgraduates. Sage Publications.

Wittingham, J., Huffman, S., Christensen, R., & McAllister, T. (2013). Use of Audiobooks in a School Library and Positive Effects of Struggling Readers’ Participation in a Library-Sponsored Audiobook Club. Research Journal of the American Association of School Librarians, 16. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1012831.pdf.

Wilson Van Voorhis, C., & Morgan, B. (2007) Understanding Power and Rules of Thumb for Determining Sample Sizes, Tutorials in Quantitative Methods for Psychology, 3(2), 43-50. doi: 10.20982/tqmp.03.2.p043

 

Appendix A

 

Self-Completion Questionnaires

 

How I feel about reading pre self-completion questionnaire

https://forms.gle/bcxGKRk6MfVn611u5

 

 

 

How I feel about reading post self-completion questionnaire.

https://forms.gle/2fpiWmHPQgigiuuV7

 

 

 

 

Appendix B

 

Statistical analysis of information gathered through the Accelerated Reading program

 

 

Appendix C

 

Ethics Forms:

 

  • Minimal Risk Checklist

 

  • Information for Participants

 

  • Consent Form

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

HUMAN RESEARCH ETHICS COMMITTEE

 

Minimal Risk Review Checklist

 

Please complete the checklist below to ascertain whether your research project would be eligible to be submitted to your School’s Ethics in Human Research Committee (SEHRC) for ethical review as a minimal risk research. Student researchers must review the completed checklist with their supervisors. If you answer “YES” to any items in the checklist your project would normally not be eligible for submission to the appropriate School Ethics Committee for review (unless you can make a special case – refer section 6) and you should complete an ethics application form NEAF and email it to ethics@csu.edu.au for review by the Human Research Ethics Committee.

 

 

Please note MINIMAL RISK research can be defined as where the foreseeable risk to participants is no more than one of discomfort. For example:

  • questionnaires and/or surveys, anonymous or otherwise, online etc. involving non-sensitive topics
  • observations, with or without consent

For more information, refer to the National Statement on ethical conduct in human research 2007  Chapter 2.1: Risk and Benefit.

 

 

Timing constraints are not an acceptable reason for seeking expedited review through this process where projects are of more than everyday risk.

 

 

PROJECT TITLE

 

Benefits of Audiobooks for students with learning difficulties/disabilities or EAL/D backgrounds.
CHIEF INVESTIGATOR

Name (Title/ given name / family name)

Qualifications

Student No(if applicable)

 

 

Miss Belinda Dunn

 

B. Ag Econ, Dip Edu

99921379

 

SUPERVISOR

Name (Title/given name / family name)

Qualifications

Mr James Deehan
School/Research Centre/ External Organisation (of Chief Investigator or supervisor)

 

Charles Sturt University
Level of Study

(eg Undergraduate practicum/clinical research project, Honours research project, postgraduate Masters or PhD)

Course

Master of Teacher Librarian

Subject Title and Code

Introduction to Educational Research

EER500

Brief outline of the project (2 lines)

To discover the benefits of audiobooks on reading fluency, comprehension test scores and engagement with reading for students with learning difficulties/disabilities or EAL/D backgrounds.

 

  1. EXTERNAL REQUIREMENTS

 

Is the research being funded by an agency outside the University, which requires Human Research Ethics Committee approval involving community representation? [If you have answered “YES” to this question you must forward the CSU  ethics application form to the Human Research Ethics Committee]  YES ü NO
Is the project hosted/auspiced by an organisation other than CSU If you have answered “No” proceed to point 2. Risk Assessment  YES ü NO
Is the project seen as being ‘owned’ primarily by the Organisation or CSU If the organisation provide  
Name of host organisation

 

Brief outline of the project (2 lines)

 

Approval process followed including committees/position of person(s) approving the proposal

 

Agreement about Intellectual Property of researcher and organisation

 

 

2.         RISK ASSESSMENT

 

A.   Are any of the following topics to be covered in part or in whole?

 

research involving children and young people

 

üYES  NO
research about parenting

 

 YES ü NO
research investigating sensitive personal issues

 

 YES ü NO
research investigating sensitive cultural issues

 

 YES üNO
explorations of grief, death or serious/traumatic loss

 

 YES ü NO
depression, mood states, anxiety

 

 YES ü NO
gambling

 

 YES üNO
eating disorders

 

 YES üNO
illicit drug taking

 

 YES üNO
substance abuse

 

 YES üNO
self report of criminal behaviour

 

 YES ü NO
any psychological disorder

 

 YES üNO
suicide

 

 YES üNO
gender identity

 

 YES üNO
sexuality

 

 YES üNO
race or ethnic identity

 

 YES üNO
any disease or health problem

 

 YES üNO
fertility

 

 YES üNO
termination of pregnancy

 

 YES üNO
anger management

 

 YES üNO
impulse control

 

 YES üNO
self esteem

 

 YES üNO
domestic violence

 

 YES üNO
elderly neglect

 

 YES üNO
divorce

 

 YES  NO
üNO
adults abused as children

 

 YES üNO
participant(s) being asked to provide information on another person

 

 YES üNO
any similar topic of possible concern

 

 YES üNO
use of researcher devised questionnaire researching a sensitive topic (eg.. depression)

 

 YES üNO

 

B.   Are any of the following procedures to be employed?

 

use of personal data obtained from organisations (including Commonwealth or State Government Department/Agency)

 

 YES üNO
deception of participants

 

 YES üNO
concealing the purposes of the research

 

 YES üNO
covert observation

 

 YES üNO
audio or visual recording without consent

 

 YES üNO
recruitment via a third party or agency

 

 YES üNO
withholding from one group specific treatments or methods of learning, from  which they

may “benefit” (e.g., in medicine or teaching)

 

 YES üNO
any psychological interventions or treatments

 

 YES üNO
administration of physical stimulation

 

 YES üNO
invasive physical procedures

 

 YES üNO
infliction of pain

 

 YES üNO
administration of drugs

 

 YES üNO
administration of other substances

 

 YES üNO
administration of ionising radiation

 

 YES üNO
tissue sampling or blood taking

 

 YES üNO
collecting body fluid

 

 YES üNO
genetic testing/DNA extraction

 

 YES üNO
use of medical records where participants can be identified or linked

 

 YES üNO
drug trials and other clinical trials

 

 YES üNO
administration of drugs or placebos

 

 YES üNO
potentially humiliating tasks

 

 YES üNO
any other similar procedures

 

 YES üNO

 

 

 

C. Other Risks

 

 

Are there any risks to the researcher, (e.g. research undertaken in unsafe, isolated environments or trouble spots)?

 

 YES üNO

 

 

3.           PARTICIPANT VULNERABILITY ASSESSMENT

 

Does the research specifically target participants from any of the following groups?

 

suffering a psychological disorder

 

 YES üNO
suffering a physical vulnerability

 

 YES üNO
people highly dependent on medical care

 

 YES üNO
minors without parental or guardian consent

 

 YES üNO
people whose ability to give consent is impaired

 

 YES üNO
residents of a custodial institution

 

 YES üNO
unable to give free informed consent because of difficulties in understanding information statement (eg language difficulties)

 

 YES üNO
members of a socially identifiable group with special cultural or religious needs or political vulnerabilities

 

 YES üNO
those in dependent relationship with the researchers (eg lecturer/student, doctor/patient, teacher/pupil, professional/client)

 

 YES üNO
those in a social/personal relationship (eg friendship) with the researcher/s  YES üNO
participants able to be identified in any final report when specific consent for this has not been given

 

 YES üNO
Indigenous Australians

 

 YES üNO
small sample size which may lead to participant identification in final report

 

 YES üNO
any similar vulnerability concerns

 

 YES üNO

 

  1. RESEARCH LOCATION ASSESSMENT

 

Location of interviews:

 

interviews being conducted in participant’s home

 

 YES üNO
interviews being conducted in an isolated area

 

 YES üNO
any other similar concerns

 

 YES üNO

 

  1. RESEARCH IN OVERSEAS SETTINGS ASSESSMENT

 

Does the research involve any of the following:

 

research being undertaken in a politically unstable area

 

 YES üNO
research involving sensitive cultural issues

 

 YES üNO
research in countries where criticism of government and institutions might put participants and/or researchers at risk

 

 YES üNO

 

  1. SPECIAL CASE ASSESSMENT

 

If you have answered “YES” to an item in the checklist but you still believe that because of the particular nature of the project and the participants your project may still be eligible for expedited review. Please provide details below, or attach an additional sheet. You must then submit these reasons with the checklist to the Chair of your School’s Ethics in Human Research Committee (SEHRC) for consideration and approval of your special case.

 

SPECIAL CASE DETAILS: Whilst this research involves children and young people considerable planning has taken place to ensure that there will be no harm to participants, informed consent of participants will be gained in a timely fashion to ensure that any questions regarding the research process can be adequately answered, privacy of participants will be ensured throughout the research process and deception in the research process will be avoided through transparency of the research process. For further information regarding the ethical considerations of this research project please see Section 5: Ethical Considerations of the research project.
 

RESEARCHER SIGNATURE: Belinda Dunn ……………………………………………………………………………………………………

SUPERVISOR’S SIGNATURE (if applicable)
APPROVAL BY SEHRC OF SPECIAL CASE

The SEHRC has met and considered the special case details associated with this project and agree / do not agree that the project can be submitted to the School Ethics in Human Research Committee for review.

 

Other comments:

 

 

SEHRC CHAIR SIGNATURE: ……………………………………………………………………………………………………

 

If you have answered “NO” to all items, attach this checklist to your completed NEAF and submit to your School’s Ethics in Human Research Committee (SEHRC). Please note the SEHRC may forward your application onto the HREC for review if they deem your research not to be minimal risk.

 

If you have answered “YES” to one item or more and are NOT requesting a special case email your completed NEAF to ethics@csu.edu for review by the full Human Research Ethics Committee.

 

Information for Research Participants

You are invited to participate in a research project called Benefits of Audiobooks for students with learning difficulties/disabilities or EAL/D backgrounds that is being undertaken by BELINDA DUNN as a part of her Master of Teacher Librarian degree at Charles Sturt University.

 

PURPOSE OF THE RESEARCH

The purpose of this research is to trial the use of audiobooks as a method to motivate and engage students in reading while improving students reading fluency and comprehension. The data from the trial will help the researcher to develop an understanding of the benefits of audiobooks in the educational setting. The results of the trial will help the researcher to refine the methods that could be used in later stages of the study with a larger number of students/schools.

 

Students with learning difficulties/disabilities or have English as an Additional Language or Dialect (EAL/D) often experience difficulties in comprehending text and reading fluency when reading traditional print material. Audiobooks can offer more time for reading, lead to independent reading, serve as a model of verbal fluency, motivate reluctant readers, improve comprehension, as well assist the English vocabulary development of EAL/D students; these benefits ultimately lead to greater educational outcomes for students.

 

YOUR STUDENTS’ INVOLVEMENT

Your students’ involvement in this study is entirely voluntary. If you decide you would like your student to participate, they will take part in pre and post self-completion questionnaires and assessed using the Accelerated Reader program.

 

POSSIBLE RISKS, INCONVENIENCES AND DISCOMFORTS

All information collected in this research will be treated with the strictest confidence and will be destroyed when I have completed my studies in this subject. You will be not be identified by name, and no details that may identify you or your affiliation will be used. Pseudonyms will be used in the research report, which will be submitted to my lecturer at university as an assignment. There will be no attempt to publish the research report or any part of it or to communicate the research or its results in any presentation or document outside of the subject to which it is attached at university.

 

You are under no obligation to agree to your student participating in this research. If you do agree to take part, however, you are free to withdraw your student at any time and without providing your reasons. In the event that you decide to withdraw your students’ participation, any data collected from you will not be used and will be discarded.

Your signature below indicates that you have read this consent form, had an opportunity to ask any questions about your participation in this research and voluntarily consent to participate. You will receive a copy of this form for your records.

Name of Participant (please print):______________________________

Name of Parent/Guardian: ____________________________________

Parent/Guardian Signature: ____________________________    

Date: ______________________________

 

CONTACT:  BELINDA DUNN     0298252888      belinda.dunn@det.nsw.edu.au

You may also talk to

Mr James Deehan

jdeehan@csu.edu.au

 

 

 

 

Consent Form

Research Title: Benefits of Audiobooks for students with learning difficulties/disabilities or EAL/D backgrounds.

 

Chief Investigator: Belinda Dunn

 

 

I agree to my students participating in the above research project and give my consent freely.

 

I understand that the project will be conducted as described in the Information Statement, a copy of which I have retained.

 

I understand I can withdraw my student from the project at any time and do not have to give any reason for withdrawing.

 

I consent to my student:

  • completing pre and post self-completion questionnaires

 

  • being assessed using the Accelerated Reader program.

 

I understand that my students personal information will remain confidential to the researchers.

 

I have had the opportunity to have questions answered to my satisfaction.

 

Student Name: ________________________________

 

Parent/Guardian Name:___________________________________

 

Parent/Guardian Signature: ____________________________________

 

Date: _________________________

 

NOTE: The Faculty of Education Human Research Ethics Committee has approved this project. If you have any complaints or reservations about the ethical conduct of this project, you may contact the Committee through the Executive Officer.

 

James Deehan

 

Any issues you raise will be treated in confidence and investigated fully and you will be informed of the outcome.

 

EER500: Introduction to Educational Research (202060)
Assignment
2 –Research Proposal (60%)

Formative Criteria SY US
Appropriate use of writing conventions. Is coherent, structured and of an acceptable standard of writing. Lacks coherence, structure and/or has serious deficiencies in the quality of the writing.
Correct use of a reference list and correct in-text referencing techniques consistent with APA 7 referencing style. Referencing conforms to APA 7 referencing style.

And

At least 10 relevant scholarly sources have been cited.

Referencing is omitted, or does not conform to APA 7 referencing style.

And/ or

Fewer than 10 relevant scholarly sources have been cited.

Appropriate completion of CSU’s Ethics in Human Research Committee’s ‘Minimal Risk Review Checklist’ A completed copy of CSU’s Ethics in Human Research Committee’s ‘Minimal Risk Review Checklist’ has been attached
And

The ‘Minimal Risk Review Checklist’ document has been filled out accurately, honestly and with no major errors.

A copy of CSU’s Ethics in Human Research Committee’s ‘Minimal Risk Review Checklist’ has been omitted
And/ or

The ‘Minimal Risk Review Checklist’ document has issues with accuracy and honesty; or has major errors in its delivery.

 

Criterion One HD DI CR PS FL
8.5-10 7.5-8.4 6.5-7.4 5-6.4 <4.9
Identification of proposed topic

 

10 marks

The section both orients the reader to the research domain and the proposal. A strong, persuasive and relational argument is made.

 

Identifies a novel research topic (i.e. an area which has not yet been addressed in the literature) by providing specific definitions partly taken from scholarly literature and adapted for the research context.

 

Provides specific and nuanced definitions for all key concepts being addressed by the research. There is evidence that scholarly definitions have been adapted for the research context.

 

The section both orients the reader to the research domain and the proposal. A strong, persuasive argument is made.

 

Identifies a more specific (multiple secondary points may be considered, such as level, method, measure, etc.) research topic by providing specific definitions taken from scholarly literature.

 

 

Provides general, yet appropriate, definitions for all key concepts being addressed by the research. There’s evidence that scholarly definitions have been adapted for the research context.

The section both orients the reader to the research domain and the proposal and persuades the reader.

 

 

Identifies a specific (secondary points may be considered, such as level, method, measure, etc.) research topic by providing general definitions partly taken from scholarly literature.

 

Provides general, yet appropriate, definitions for all key concepts being addressed by the research through the use of scholarly literature.

 

The section adequately orients the reader to the research domain and the proposal.

 

 

Identifies a relatively broad, yet acceptable area for the proposed research.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Provides general, yet appropriate, definitions for all key concepts being addressed by the research.

 

Does not meet pass criteria – See commentary for specific details

 

 

 

Criterion Two HD DI CR PS FL
8.5-10 7.5-8.4 6.5-7.4 5-6.4 <4.9
Literature Review

 

10 marks

The findings of an array of appropriate scholarly sources are described accurately and grouped thematically (paragraphs/ subheadings). There is little to no repetitiveness/ redundancy. Critical comparisons of findings between different scholarly sources are a main part of the structure. The author uses the critical comparisons to justify and signpost research directions.

 

The methods of an array of appropriate scholarly sources are described accurately and discussed in relation to intended purpose. There is little to no repetitiveness/ redundancy. There is evidence of critical comparisons of methods between different scholarly sources; with possible shortcomings identified. Some suggestions are made for methodological improvement/ alternatives.

 

Lists some (>4) specific gaps/ limitations/ problems within the literature that can be addressed by the research proposal. Research findings, methods and context are considered overtly. The link between the body of literature and the research question is clear and signposted throughout the section. The research question is clearly positioned and justified.

 

The findings of an array of appropriate scholarly sources are described accurately and grouped thematically (paragraphs/ subheadings). There is little to no repetitiveness/ redundancy. There is evidence of critical comparisons of findings between different scholarly sources.

 

 

 

The methods of an array of appropriate scholarly sources are described accurately and discussed in relation to intended purpose. There is little to no repetitiveness/ redundancy. There is evidence of critical comparisons of methods between different scholarly sources; with possible shortcomings identified.

 

 

 

 

Lists some (3-4) specific gaps/ limitations/ problems within the literature that can be addressed by the research proposal. Research findings, methods and context are considered overtly. The link between the body of literature and the research question is clear and signposted throughout the section.

 

The findings of an array of appropriate scholarly sources are described accurately and grouped thematically (paragraphs/ subheadings). There is little to no repetitiveness/ redundancy

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The methods of an array of appropriate scholarly sources are described accurately and discussed in relation to intended purpose. There is little to no repetitiveness/ redundancy

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Lists some (2-3) general gaps/ limitations/ problems within the literature that can be addressed by the research proposal. Research findings and methods are considered overtly. The link between the body of literature and the research question may be thematically appropriate but somewhat tangential/ limited.

The findings of an appropriate array of scholarly sources are described accurately. There may be some element of redundancy/ repetitiveness.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The methods of an appropriate array of scholarly literature are described accurately (some informal language may still be evident).

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Lists some (1-2) general gaps/ limitations/ problems within the literature that can be addressed by the research proposal. The link between the body of literature and the research question may be thematically appropriate but somewhat tangential/ limited.

Does not meet pass criteria – See commentary for specific details

 

 

 

Criterion Three HD DI CR PS FL
8.5-10 7.5-8.4 6.5-7.4 5-6.4 <4.9
Theoretical perspective and methodology

 

10 marks

Draws on both the textbook and additional subject readings to identify and describe a perspective/ methodology/ paradigm that relates closely to the proposed topic and research question. Recognises overlaps and complements in this area. Relates the perspective/ methodology/ paradigm back to the existing literature and forward to the research design. Alternatives may be considered and dismissed based on the literature reviewed. Draws on both the textbook and additional subject readings to identify and describe a perspective/ methodology/ paradigm that relates closely to the proposed topic and research question. Begins to recognise overlaps and complements in this area. Alternatives may be considered and dismissed thoughtfully (i.e. research methods literature).

 

Draws on both the textbook and additional subject readings to describe and explain a perspective/ methodology/ paradigm that relates closely to the proposed topic and research question. Alternatives may be considered and dismissed logically.

 

 

Draws on the textbook to identify and describe a perspective/ methodology/ paradigm that broadly relates to the proposed topic and research question. Alternatives may be considered.

 

 

 

Does not meet pass criteria – See commentary for specific details

 

 

 

Criterion Four HD DI CR PS FL
17-20 15-16.8 13-14.8 10-12.8 <9.9
Proposed Study Design (Method)

 

20 marks

Provides a detailed, accurate description of the research methods to be employed within the research project. There is an explicit use of the core subject text(s). There is clear evidence of wider reading beyond the subject materials. The strengths and weaknesses of specific qualitative and quantitative methods are described in a critical and synthesized way. Deep insight is evident. There is a logical flow of ideas and an ongoing theme throughout the section.

 

The sampling procedures and sample are described in a clear and ethically appropriate way. Literature is unpacked to enrich the subsection. The challenges and considerations of research sampling are addressed overtly. There’s some evidence of critical insight. Makes worthy connections to other aspects of the methods section.

 

Provides a specific, procedural and layered description of how the data will be analysed in relation to the research question. The differences between data types and purposes is considered overtly. There is some use of literature beyond the core subject material. Valid and reliable/ credible and trustworthy data analysis procedures may be articulated. The data analysis procedures are fully replicable with clear steps.

Provides a detailed, accurate description of the research methods to be employed within the research project. There is an explicit use of the core subject text(s). There is some evidence of wider reading beyond the subject materials. The strengths and weaknesses of specific qualitative and quantitative methods are discussed in a critical and synthesized way.

 

 

 

 

The sampling procedures and sample are described in a clear and ethically appropriate way. Literature is unpacked to enrich the subsection. The challenges and considerations of research sampling are addressed overtly.

 

 

 

 

 

Provides a specific, procedural description of how the data will be analysed in relation to the research question. The differences between data types and purposes is considered overtly. Literature beyond the core subject material is used to enrich the subsection.

 

 

Provides a detailed, accurate description of the research methods to be employed within the research project. There is an explicit use of the core subject text(s). The strengths and weaknesses of specific qualitative and quantitative methods are discussed.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The sampling procedures and sample are described in a clear and ethically appropriate way. Literature is unpacked to enrich the subsection.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Provides a specific description of how the data will be analysed in relation to the research question. The differences between data types and purposes is considered overtly. There is some use of literature beyond the core subject material.

 

 

Provides a sound, accurate description of the research methods to be employed within the research project. There is a generally appropriate use of the core subject text(s). The strengths and weaknesses of qualitative and quantitative approaches are described.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The sampling procedures and sample are described in a clear and ethically appropriate way.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Provides a general description of how the data will be analysed in relation to the research question. Research methods literature has been referenced appropriately.

 

Does not meet pass criteria – See commentary for specific details

 

Criterion Five HD DI CR PS FL
8.5-10 7.5-8.4 6.5-7.4 5-6.4 <4.9
Ethical Considerations

 

10 marks

Identifies and describes ethical issues relevant to the specific research context described in the proposal. Articulates all of the ethical challenges that may need to be addressed in the proposed project. Discusses the balance between the need for rich research data and the need to uphold participants’ rights. Explicit, synthesised and critical use of core and expanded literature is used to enrich the writing.

 

Discusses clear and replicable procedures for how the specific research should be conducted over the course of the research project. There are no cognitive leaps required on the part of the reader. Deep, critical use of core and expanded literature is used to enrich the writing.

Identifies and describes ethical issues relevant to the specific research context described in the proposal. Articulates some of the ethical challenges that may need to be addressed in the proposed project. Explicit, synthesised use of core and expanded literature is used to enrich the writing.

 

 

 

 

 

Outlines clear and replicable procedures for how the specific research should be conducted over the course of the research project. There are few cognitive leaps required on the part of the reader. Deep use of core and expanded literature is used to enrich the writing.

 

Identifies and describes ethical issues relevant to the specific research context described in the proposal. Explicit use of core literature is used to enrich the writing.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Makes general, acceptable suggestions for how research can be conducted ethically in the specific context described in the proposal. There are still some cognitive required leaps on the part of the reader. Deep use of core literature is used to enrich the writing.

Identifies and describes universal aspects of ethical issues applicable to educational research. Base links to core literature are evident.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Makes some general, acceptable suggestions for how research can be conducted ethically in school contexts. There are many cognitive leaps required on the part of the reader. Base links to core literature are evident.

 

Does not meet pass criteria – See commentary for specific details

 

 

 

Marking Rubric for Students (see above for more detailed information)

A2: – Research Proposal (60%) Value Mark
Use of academic language conventions SY/UN SY
Adherence to APA 6th referencing conventions SY/UN SY
Minimal Review Checklist SY/UN SY
Identification of proposed research topic 10 8.5
Literature Review 10 8.5
Theoretical perspective and methodology 10 8
Proposed Study Design (Method) 20 14.5
Ethical Considerations 10 7.5
TOTAL 60 47

 

Mark out of 60:  47                          Percentage:  78%                                             Grade:  Distinction                                         

 

Marker: Dr James Deehan

 

Please follow this link to access your audio feedback – https://drive.google.com/file/d/1qboOu3qYLB-wBhh5GVsliMHNniP32QgI/view?usp=sharing

Important note: Be sure to download the file to your computer by clicking on the icon in the top right corner of your browser.

 

Posted in EER 500 | Tagged | Leave a comment

Literature Analysis and Research Question.

Proposed Topic

 

Audiobooks are described as a digitized work. Digitized works are defined as a work conceived for another medium, such as the printed medium (Bouchard and Heckmann 2012). The Association of American Publishers found that the audiobook market is the fastest growing publishing format, with audiobook sales increasing by over 40% in 2018 (Trombetta, 2019; Poole, 2019; Catalano, 2018), and the global market expected to grow by another 25% in 2020 (Thorp, 2020). The audiobook market is meeting the growing needs of the time poor consumer; providing the opportunity to multitask with other activities whilst listening to their favourite books. Audiobooks are also becoming more creative and ambitious with a number of authors now producing new works which are only available as an audiobook format with popular actors employed to narrate the stories; recent studies have found that listeners are more emotionally engaged with audiobooks when compared to watching television or movies (Trombetta, 2019; Catalano, 2018; Esteves & Whitten, 2011).

 

Audiobooks are also becoming increasingly popular in the education setting, as they have been shown to benefit students’ literacy through listening to pronunciation and intonation, as well as increasing the students’ exposure to words; audiobooks also provide the listener with the opportunity to change the speed of narration, further enhancing students with lowered literacy the opportunity to better understand and comprehend the storyline.  Lamb (2011, p. 16), Johnson (2009, p. 105) and Labbo (2000, p. 543) describe the benefits of audiobooks to students through differentiating instruction – audiobooks can offer more time for reading, serve as a model of verbal fluency, motivate reluctant readers, and improve the English vocabulary development of English as an additional language or dialect (EAL/D) students; these benefits ultimately lead to greater educational outcomes for students.

 

This review will focus on academic literature, which investigates the benefits of audiobooks for students with learning difficulties, disabilities or have an EAL/D background and consider how audiobooks assist school students in literacy development. This review is relevant due to the increasing number of enrolled students in a SW Sydney high school with learning difficulties/disabilities or EAL/D backgrounds, who have low literacy or engagement with reading. The review will discuss the main methods used to select literature related to the topic, the types of research analysis used within the research, as well as weaknesses, limitations and possible gaps of the reviewed literature. Responding to these gaps, a potential relevant research question will be proposed for further consideration.

 

Literature Search Method

 

The initial search of the benefits of audiobooks was very broad and as such led to a large number of results, as shown in Table 1; this table shows the very basic development of search terms for the review. As this was the beginning of the search process, this search term was used with Primo Search, Google Scholar and Educational Resources Information Centre (ERIC); an extremely large number of articles were related to this search term, with Google Scholar yielding over 500,000 pages of results. While there were a large number of results the vast majority were not relevant as they did not necessarily relate to education or improving literacy, which is the main topic focus. A large number of results were weighted towards books and dissertations; searches were refined to peer-reviewed articles and further development of search terms took place.

 

From the initial review of literature and meta-analyses (Bryman, 2016, p. 318), a number of authors were identified as being significant, this led to author searches being included as part of the literature search, bibliographic branching and related article recommendations were also used in the search process. The State Library of NSW and Journal Storage (JSTOR) were included as additional scholarly search approaches which assisted in further development of search terms and articles relevant for the review. Table 2 shows the keyword search combinations which were used.

 

An identified issue when searching journal articles related to EAL/D, was that various terms are used to describe English as a Second Language users depending on the country of origin of the studies, a number of different search terms were employed to overcome this. It was difficult to find any articles that related to the use of audiobooks in Australian education settings, with only one article mentioning Australia (Ness & Berry, 2013), suggesting a large gap in the literature for Australian schools, the use of more specific Australian terminology may have assisted in finding relevant articles. Additional author searches, bibliographic branching and related article recommendations from scholarly articles would have further assisted this literature review, time and word constraints made this difficult to complete. The use of EndNote would also have assisted in completing the literature review for this assignment, to assist with organisation of the articles which were reviewed.

 

 

Table 1: Initial search term development.

 

Search term Result
benefits of audiobooks A very large number of results, not all educationally relevant.
audiobook inclusivity Smaller broader results, not necessarily relevant.
audiobooks AND education More results targeting education specifically.

 

 

Table 2: Search term combinations.

 

audiobooks AND low literacy audiobook inclusivity “special education” audiobook equality autism
audiobooks disability data audiobooks disability measuring success “audiobooks” AND low literacy
audiobook AND reading difficulty Dyslexia AND audiobook OR talking book “audiobook” AND “reading disability” AND school*
audiobooks AND EALD audiobooks AND EFL AND school* audiobook AND EFL AND education
“audiobook” AND “reading disability” AND school* AND “Australia” “Chang, Anna Ching-Shyang” and audiobooks “Esteves, Kelli” AND reading disabilities

 

Review of Literature

 

Reading benefits students’ cognitive development and academic success (Moore & Cahill, 2016), which ultimately leads to student engagement and remaining at school to complete their studies; for students with learning difficulties, disabilities or an EAL/D background the ability to read and comprehend what they are reading is diminished.  A significant number of studies found that there is benefit to student engagement and learning when audiobooks are used to enhance reading for EAL/D and learning difficulties/disabilities, however, numerous gaps exist in the research surrounding these benefits and there are no significant studies for Australian students.

 

An American meta analysis study (Bryman, 2016, p. 318) completed by Moore & Cahill (2016) was the only study which considered the use of audiobooks with adolescents with learning disabilities, EAL/D and students with typical patterns of development together. With regards to EAL/D students Moore & Cahill (2016) and Alcantud-Diaz & Gregori-Signes (2014) found that students’ reading comprehension, spoken interaction and writing improved with the use of audiobooks. The use of audio content has historically been used in EAL/D education and the research supports this delivery. Similarly a mixed method study; involving quantitative data from comprehension skills testing and qualitative data from participants’ opinions about the use of audiobooks (Bryman, 2016, p. 193-194; Creswell, 2012, p.22)  was undertaken in Turkey with 66 first year university students (Kartal & Simsek, 2017) results identified positive outcomes of using audiobooks with EAL/D students. Whilst this study was based on students aged 18-22, which is out of the age range of school age students, their results showed significantly higher general listening comprehension skills post trial. Quantitative results in this trial showed students believed the audiobooks improved their reading and listening comprehension; students found hearing the correct pronunciation of words assisted in improving their pronunciation; these outcomes would be of benefit for Australian EAL/D students in their education in mainstream classes.

 

Finally, a Taiwanese study (Chang & Millett, 2015) and a Spanish study (Tragant Mestres, Llanes Baró, & Pinyana Garriga 2018) were the most robust qualitative studies. These studies involved 64 year 10 secondary students and 100 upper primary school students respectively; making the sample sizes significantly reasonable (Wilson Van Voorhis & Morgan, 2007 p. 48) and implemented an ANOVA test measure (Lewis-Beck, Bryman & Futing, 2004, p. 657) to discover the significant differences between silent reading and audiobook reading for reading rates and comprehension. One issue with the Taiwanese study was there was no control group of students however this study is the most relevant in regards to ages of students studied, the results of this study found a large effect size on improving reading rates, comprehension and enjoyment with using audiobooks. Conversely, the Spanish study found no significant improvement in test results, a reason for this may have been the shorter intervention period and the material used with the trial; however, students’ engagement with audiobook reading was shown to be much higher.  Importantly, the studies researched were located in countries with non-English speaking backgrounds learning English; the Greek study with students outside the age range of school students. As such, the translatability of profiles may be difficult to the Australian school context and limits generalisability to our school system (McMillan & Wergin, 2010, p. 12-13)

 

Students with learning difficulties and disabilities encounter significant learning barriers and are often negatively impacted due to their accessibility to printed reading material when compared to their peers. The use of audiobooks provides these students with greater independence, access and ultimately assists in their motivation to read, literary learning and ability to meet the demands of the curriculum. The meta analysis research for students with learning difficulties completed by Moore & Cahill (2016); Stevens, Walker & Vaughan (2014) and Ness & Berry (2013) showed some positive outcomes, including greater independence and accessibility.  The Moore & Cahill (2016) also reported students improved motivation to read and some reading comprehension development; however, the improvements shown in this study were not significant. The Stevens et al. (2014) meta synthesis review was the most robust in terms of criteria of studies reviewed; their findings highlighted that repeated reading with the use of audiobooks benefits students with learning disabilities, however, small sample sizes and treatment duration were limitations to the research designs.

 

Results from a number of studies found improvements in accessibility, reading comprehension, fluency and attitudes to reading (Whittingham, Huffman, Christensen & McAllister, 2013; Esteves & Whitten, 2011; Davies, Stock, King & Wehmeyer, 2008; Boyle, Rosenberg, Connelly, Washburn, Brinckerhoff & Banerjee, 2003) when audiobooks are incorporated into reading programs. The Boyle et al. (2003) study is aged and there has been considerable improvements in the delivery of audio material from that time, as discussed in the introduction, this study was also limited to six weeks which may have limited the true outcomes of using audiobooks, even though the ANOVA test results are positive for the use of audiobooks. Similarly the Davies et al. (2008) study was also a short time period, eight weeks, age of participants was higher than school age and considered the impact of functionality and accessibility rather than the measurement of literacy improvement, the technological advancements since 2008 must be taken into account when considering this research. While the researchers did use more robust analysis tools; ANOVA, the small sample sizes and average age of participants; 28.47 years, limits the generalisability of this study.

 

In addition, two studies (Whittingham et al., 2013; Esteves & Whitten, 2011) used mixed methods approaches for their research. Esteves & Whitten (2011) found positive impacts of audiobooks on reading fluency, however, no significant difference to reading attitudes was found. Conversely Whittingham et al. (2013) who triangulated results (Bryman, 2016, p. 386; McMillan & Wergin, 2010, p. 12; Punch, 2005, p. 309) to verify consistencies in their findings, discovered reading attitudes and comprehension both improved with the use of audiobooks. Small sample sizes are an identified limitation to the generalisability of both study results.

 

All reviewed research papers for students with reading difficulties/disabilities are from America, making it difficult to generalise the study results to Australian schools; it can be concluded that while some evidence suggests the benefits of audiobooks there are significant gaps in the research. Further in-depth studies, with larger participant groups and longer timeframes are required to ultimately discover the benefits of audiobooks to literacy development for students with learning disabilities and difficulties.

 

 

Weaknesses, Limitations and Gaps in the Reviewed Literature

 

As mentioned throughout the review, there are a number of weaknesses, limitations and gaps in the literature which was reviewed for this analysis. The most significant identified issue is that none of the reviewed studies took place in Australian schools, this makes it difficult to generalise the results of the previous research to Australian education settings.

 

The age of the studies is also an identified weakness, with older studies ranging from 2008 – 2016, only two studies were undertaken within the last four years (Kartal & Simsek, 2017; Tragant Mestres, Llanes Baró, & Pinyana Garriga 2018). As stated in the introduction there has been considerable development in the production of audiobooks as well as the technology available to listen to audio recordings; this ultimately influences students’ access and engagement with audiobooks.

 

Another limiting factor of the reviewed literature was the length of study periods. A number of studies only undertook research for a six week (Boyle et al. 2003) or eight week (Esteves & Whitten 2011; Davies et al. 2008) time period, with such short time frames, it makes it difficult to conclude the validity of the research (Wallace & Wray, 2006, p. 27).

 

The age of participants in a number of studies (Davies et al. 2008; Kartal & Simsek, 2017) also limits generalisability, as the participants in these studies had an average age over the general age of school populations.

 

Proposal for Further Research

 

Through in-depth research of the available literature on the benefits of audiobooks for students with learning difficulties/disabilities or EAL/D a number of weaknesses and limitations to the studies have been identified. Further research within the Australian context is required to discover the impacts of using audiobooks for the identified groups of students. As such the following research question is proposed.

 

Does an extensive audiobook program at a SW Sydney high school covary with improved reading comprehension test scores and engagement with reading for students with learning difficulties/disabilities or EALD backgrounds?

References

 

Alcantud-Diaz, M. and Gregori-Signes, C., 2013. Audiobooks: improving fluency and instilling literary skills and education for development. Directory of open access journals, 20(1), pp.111-125. https://doaj.org/article/40c57792d3c643d09282d7651f3adcab

Bourchardon, S. & Heckman, D. (2012). Digital manipulability and digital literature. Electronic Book Review http://www.electronicbookreview.com/thread/electropoetics/heuristic

Boyle, E. A., Rosenberg, M. S., Connelly, V. J., Washburn, S. G., Brinckerhoff, L. C., & Banerjee, M. (2003). Effects of Audio Texts on the Acquisition of Secondary-Level Content by Students with Mild Disabilities. Learning Disability Quarterly, 26(3), 203–214. https://doi-org.ezproxy.csu.edu.au/10.2307/1593652

Bryman, A. (2016). Social research methods (5th ed.). Oxford University Press.

Catalano, F. (2018, August 11). Listen up: Digital audiobooks now the ‘fastest growing format’ as tech and titles improve. GeekWire. https://www.geekwire.com/2018/listen-digital-audiobooks-now-fastest-growing-format-tech-titles-improve/

Chang, A., & Millett, S. (2015). Improving reading rates and comprehension through audio-assisted extensive reading for beginner learners. System, 52, 91-102. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.system.2015.05.003

Creswell, J. (2012). The process of conducting research using quantitative and qualitative approaches. In Educational research: planning, conducting and evaluating quantitative and qualitative research (4th ed.) (pp. 8-24). Pearson.

Davies, D., Stock, S., King, L., & Wehmeyer, M. (2008). “Moby-Dick Is My Favorite:” Evaluating a Cognitively Accessible Portable Reading System for Audiobooks for Individuals With Intellectual Disability. Intellectual And Developmental Disabilities, 46(4), 290-298. https://doi.org/10.1352/1934-9556(2008)46[290:mimfea]2.0.co;2

Elsa, T. M., Àngels Llanes Baró, & Garriga, À. P. (2019). Linguistic and non-linguistic outcomes of a reading-while-listening program for young learners of english. Reading and Writing, 32(3), 819-838. doi:http://dx.doi.org.ezproxy.csu.edu.au/10.1007/s11145-018-9886-x

Esteves, K. J., & Whitten, E., (2011). Assisted reading with digital audiobooks for students with reading disabilities. Reading Horizons, 51(1), 21-40. Retrieved from https://ezproxy.csu.edu.au/login?url=https://search-proquest-com.ezproxy.csu.edu.au/docview/873824877?accountid=10344

Johnson, P. (2009). Fundamentals of Collection Development and Management (Vol. 2nd ed). Chicago: ALA Editions.

Kartal, G., & Simsek, H. (2017). The effects of audiobooks on EFL students’ listening comprehension. The Reading Matrix: An International Online Journal, 17(1), 112-123. https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Galip_Kartal2/publication/334508194_The_Effects_of_Audiobooks_on_EFL_Students’_Listening_Comprehension/links/5d2ed4a292851cf4408a88be/The-Effects-of-Audiobooks-on-EFL-Students-Listening-Comprehension.pdf

Labbo, L. (2000). 12 Things Young Children Can Do with a Talking Book in a Classroom Computer Center. The Reading Teacher, 53(7), 542-546. www.jstor.org/stable/20204838

Lamb, A. (2011). Reading redefined for a transmedia universe. Learning and leading with technology, 39(3), 12-17. http://ezproxy.csu.edu.au/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/ login.aspx?direct=true&db=ehh&AN=67371172&site=ehost-live

Lewis-Beck, M. S., Bryman, A., & Futing Liao, T. (2004). The SAGE encyclopedia of social science research methods (Vols. 1-0). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, Inc. doi: 10.4135/9781412950589

McMillan, J. H. & Wergin, J. F. (2010). Introduction to reading educational research. Understanding and evaluating educational research (4th ed.). Pearson/Merrill.

Milani, A., Lorusso, M. L., & Molteni, M. (2010). The effects of audiobooks on the psychosocial adjustment of pre-adolescents and adolescents with dyslexia. Dyslexia (10769242), 16(1), 87–97. https://doi-org.ezproxy.csu.edu.au/10.1002/dys.397

Moore, J. and Cahill, M., 2016. Audiobooks: Legitimate “Reading” Material for Adolescents? Research Journal of the American Association of School Libraries, 19. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1120838.pdf

Nees, M., & Berry, L. (2013). Audio assistive technology and accommodations for students with visual impairments: Potentials and problems for delivering curricula and educational assessments. Performance Enhancement & Health, 2(3), 101-109. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.peh.2013.08.016

Poole, S. (2019, July 13). Listen up: why we can’t get enough of audiobooks. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/books/2019/jul/13/listen-up-rise-of-audiobooks-steven-poole

Punch, K. (2005). Extract from Mixed methods and evaluation. Introduction to social research : quantitative and qualitative approaches (2nd ed.) 306-309. Sage.

Thorp, C. (2020, January 6). Audiobooks: The rise and rise of the books you don’t read. BBC. https://www.bbc.com/culture/article/20200104-audiobooks-the-rise-and-rise-of-the-books-you-dont-read

Tragant Mestres, E., Llanes Baró, À., & Pinyana Garriga, À. (2018). Linguistic and non-linguistic outcomes of a reading-while-listening program for young learners of English.  Reading and Writing, 32(3), 819-838. doi:http://dx.doi.org.ezproxy.csu.edu.au/10.1007/s11145-018-9886-x

Trombetta, S. (2019, May 24). There’s actually a scientific reason for why you love audiobooks so much. Bustle. https://www.bustle.com/p/why-audiobook-listening-is-growing-in-popularity-with-readers-17186269

Wallace, M., & Wray, A. (2006). Extracts. In Critical reading and writing for postgraduates. Sage Publications.

Wittingham, J., Huffman, S., Christensen, R., & McAllister, T. (2013). Use of Audiobooks in a School Library and Positive Effects of Struggling Readers’ Participation in a Library-Sponsored Audiobook Club. Research Journal Of The American Association Of School Librarians, 16. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1012831.pdf.

Wilson Van Voorhis, C., & Morgan, B. (2007) Understanding Power and Rules of Thumb for Determining Sample Sizes, Tutorials in Quantitative Methods for Psychology, 3(2), 43-50. doi: 10.20982/tqmp.03.2.p043

 

Appendix 1.

Literature Summary Sheet – Audio Books

  1. Article Source Information
Author(s) Moore, J. & Cahill, M.
Title Audiobooks: Legitimate “Reading” Material for Adolescents?
Year 2016
Search Information (Where and how did you find it? Primo Search – Benefits of audiobooks
Link to article http://web.b.ebscohost.com.ezproxy.csu.edu.au/ehost/pdfviewer/pdfviewer?vid=1&sid=03bd5a46-5eef-4a23-8b3e-484f1c648e51%40pdc-v-sessmgr01
Citation Moore, J., & Cahill, M. (2016). Audiobooks: Legitimate “Reading” Material for Adolescents? School Library Research, 19, 1–17.

Summary of Key Information

Who? (participants) ●     Adolescents with visual impairments or learning difficulties

●     Second language learners

●     typical developing adolescents

What? (program/ method) Lit review in audio delivery
Why? (problem/ question/ goal) Numerous gaps exists in research of adolescents & audiobooks
When? (year) 2016
Where? (context information) America
How? (what did the researcher use/ do?) Meta analysis – in depth review of past lit

Deeper analysis

Strengths EFL – increase comprehension with audiobks – German study
Weaknesses Variable outcomes of audiobook use for LD and typical
Limitations/ questions raised for you Quality of narration, longer term studies needed, how audiobks support knowledge gains & vocab development

Nuanced contbn of adiobks on lit dev & proficiencies

Relation to other literature 7, 2, 5
Relation to my research/ area of interest Some positive outcomes esp for EAL/D

 

 

  1. Article Source Information
Author(s) María Alcantud Díaz

Carmen Gregori Signes

 

Title

Audiobooks: improving fluency and instilling literary skills and education for development

Year 2014
Search Information (Where and how did you find it? Google Scholar
Link to article https://doaj.org/article/40c57792d3c643d09282d7651f3adcab
Citation Alcantud-Diaz, M. and Gregori-Signes, C., 2013. Audiobooks: improving fluency and instilling literary skills and education for development. Directory of open access journals, 20(1), pp.111-125. https://doaj.org/article/40c57792d3c643d09282d7651f3adcab

Summary of Key Information

Who? (participants) Primary education settings

Learning English

What? (program/ method) Review of Lit on how audiobks contribute to language learning
Why? (problem/ question/ goal)
When? (year) 2014
Where? (context information) Spain
How? (what did the researcher use/ do?) Critical review of a selection of articles and contribution of audiobks to language learning.

Deeper analysis

Strengths Audiobks favour and foster listening, reading, spoken interaction, spoken prodn & writing +ve impact on learners language competence + literary skills
Weaknesses Seems a fairly brief review.

Spanish

Limitations/ questions raised for you
Relation to other literature 5
Relation to my research/ area of interest

 

 

  1. Article Source Information
Author(s) Whittingham, Jeff; Huffman, Stephanie; Christensen, Rob; McAllister, Tracy
Title Use of Audiobooks in a School Library and Positive Effects of Struggling Readers’ Participation in a Library-Sponsored Audiobook Club
Year 2013
Search Information (Where and how did you find it? ERIC
Link to article https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1012831.pdf
Citation Wittingham, J., Huffman, S., Christensen, R., & McAllister, T. (2013). Use of Audiobooks in a School Library and Positive Effects of Struggling Readers’ Participation in a Library-Sponsored Audiobook Club. Research Journal Of The American Association Of School Librarians, 16. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1012831.pdf.

Summary of Key Information

Who? (participants) 21 students in Grade 4-5

Students were 2 grade levels below

What? (program/ method) School Lib book club
Why? (problem/ question/ goal) Falling behind in reading can lead to students losing interest in learning & school. Increase reading skills leads to +ve attitudes twd reading
When? (year) 2013
Where? (context information) Rural Elementary America
How? (what did the researcher use/ do?) Lib audiobook club

Quant – stdised test data

Qual – pre + post interviews, surveys, teacher, parent + student questionnaires

Mid point interviews

Deeper analysis

Strengths Student attitude twd reading + their abilities improved

Reading more due to audiobks

Audiobks with struggling readers a success

Weaknesses Small sample size

Ltd generalizability

Maturation may have lead to improvement

Limitations/ questions raised for you Further research needed to see definitive improvement in test scores from audiobks

+ve results for struggling readers

Relation to other literature 6
Relation to my research/ area of interest

 

 

  1. Article Source Information
Author(s) Labbo, L.
Title 12 Things Young Children Can Do with a Talking Book in a Classroom Computer Center.
Year 2000
Search Information (Where and how did you find it? State Library of NSW – JSTOR

Dyslexia AND audiobook OR talking book

Link to article https://www-jstor-org.ezproxy.sl.nsw.gov.au/stable/pdf/20204838.pdf
Citation Labbo, L. (2000). 12 Things Young Children Can Do with a Talking Book in a Classroom Computer Center. The Reading Teacher, 53(7), 542-546. Retrieved August 11, 2020, from www.jstor.org/stable/20204838

Summary of Key Information

Who? (participants)
What? (program/ method)
Why? (problem/ question/ goal)
When? (year)
Where? (context information)
How? (what did the researcher use/ do?)

Deeper analysis

Strengths
Weaknesses
Limitations/ questions raised for you
Relation to other literature
Relation to my research/ area of interest

 

 

  1. Article Source Information
Author(s) Kartal, G. & Simsek, H.
Title The Effects of Audiobooks on EFL Students’ Listening Comprehension
Year 2017
Search Information (Where and how did you find it? ERIC – audiobooks and second language learning.

Full article was not available on ERIC, title was copied to Google Scholar for full article.

Link to article https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Galip_Kartal2/publication/334508194_The_Effects_of_Audiobooks_on_EFL_Students’_Listening_Comprehension/links/5d2ed4a292851cf4408a88be/The-Effects-of-Audiobooks-on-EFL-Students-Listening-Comprehension.pdf
Citation Kartal, G., & Simsek, H. (2017). The effects of audiobooks on EFL students’ listening comprehension. The Reading Matrix: An International Online Journal, 17(1), 112-123.

Summary of Key Information

Who? (participants) 66 1st yr uni EFL students.

18-22 yrs old

What? (program/ method) Effect of audiobks on listening comprehension

Skills & attitudes to using audiobooks in foreign language classroom

Why? (problem/ question/ goal) Do audiobks effect EFL listening comprehension skills & what are students opinions of using audiobks
When? (year) 2017
Where? (context information) Eng Lang Teach Dept State Uni Turkey
How? (what did the researcher use/ do?) Quant – general listening skills scores pre & post

Quali – participants opinions via survey & subjected to content analysis

Deeper analysis

Strengths Control & experimental same at beginning

Listening comp statistically sig higher for audiobook use

Quali – believed improve reading & comp

Improved pronunciation

Weaknesses Study based on uni students

13 weeks

Limitations/ questions raised for you
Relation to other literature 1, 7, 11
Relation to my research/ area of interest +ve attitudes to reading

 

 

  1. Article Source Information
Author(s) Esteves, K. & Whitten, E.
Title Assisted Reading with Digital Audiobooks for Students with Reading Disabilites
Year 2011
Search Information (Where and how did you find it? Primo Search

Audiobooks and low literacy

Link to article https://search-proquest-com.ezproxy.csu.edu.au/docview/873824877?accountid=10344&rfr_id=info%3Axri%2Fsid%3Aprimo
Citation Esteves, K. J., EdD., & Whitten, E., PhD. (2011). Assisted reading with digital audiobooks for students with reading disabilities. Reading Horizons, 51(1), 21-40. Retrieved from https://ezproxy.csu.edu.au/login?url=https://search-proquest-com.ezproxy.csu.edu.au/docview/873824877?accountid=10344

Summary of Key Information

Who? (participants) 20 students from five different schools

Upper elementary with documented reading disability and IEP

What? (program/ method) Reading fluency & attitude pre & post test
Why? (problem/ question/ goal) Compare assisted reading with audiobks with sustained silent reading in terms of fluency & reading attitude
When? (year) 2011
Where? (context information) Mid Western suburban school district
How? (what did the researcher use/ do?) Use of audiobks & bks to follow along

Deeper analysis

Strengths Sig increase in post test scores for both control & treatment

Treatment group demonstrated large gains

Reading attitude increased

Weaknesses 7 wk trial

20 students

Limitations/ questions raised for you Longer trial period would benefit
Relation to other literature 3
Relation to my research/ area of interest

 

 

  1. Article Source Information
Author(s) Boyle, E. A., Rosenberg, M. S., Connelly, V. J., Washburn, S. G., Brinckerhoff, L. C., & Banerjee, M.
Title Effects of Audio Texts on the Acquisition of Secondary-Level Content by Students with Mild Disabilities
Year 2003
Search Information (Where and how did you find it? Google Scholar – Bibliographical Branching.
Link to article http://web.a.ebscohost.com.ezproxy.csu.edu.au/ehost/pdfviewer/pdfviewer?vid=1&sid=fdaf1a2d-b90e-465a-a3bd-bb0b56925650%40sdc-v-sessmgr01
Citation Boyle, E. A., Rosenberg, M. S., Connelly, V. J., Washburn, S. G., Brinckerhoff, L. C., & Banerjee, M. (2003). Effects of Audio Texts on the Acquisition of Secondary-Level Content by Students with Mild Disabilities. Learning Disability Quarterly, 26(3), 203–214. https://doi-org.ezproxy.csu.edu.au/10.2307/1593652

Summary of Key Information

Who? (participants) 95 students (dropped to 67 by end of study)

  1. Learning dif, emotional dst, speech/language impairment
  2. Specialised accommodation
  3. Permission to participate
What? (program/ method)
Why? (problem/ question/ goal)
When? (year) 2003
Where? (context information) 6 large suburban high schools in NE America

high/middle, middle/low socioeconomic

All schools had self contained classes for the study

How? (what did the researcher use/ do?) Audiobks with SLICK strat
Audio only

Control – only teacher based instn support

Deeper analysis

Strengths Shows using audiobks variable for students with mild cognitive disabilities

Increase of immediate comprehension

Weaknesses From 2003 – aged

Using CD-rom audio – tech has changed greatly

Limitations/ questions raised for you Only a 6wk trial

Generalizability of findings are ltd to similar students in self contained classrooms that serve students with LD

Audio assists students with mild LD, potential to increase students independence

Relation to other literature 1, 5
Relation to my research/ area of interest Shows audio benefits students with LD

 

 

  1. Article Source Information
Author(s) Daniel K. Davies, Steven E. Stock, Larry R. King, Michael L. Wehmeyer, David Helm;
Title “Moby-Dick Is My Favorite:” Evaluating a Cognitively Accessible Portable Reading System for Audiobooks for Individuals With Intellectual Disability.
Year 2008
Search Information (Where and how did you find it? Audiobook and disability – Primo
Link to article https://meridian-allenpress-com.ezproxy.csu.edu.au/idd/article/46/4/290/1334/Moby-Dick-Is-My-Favorite-Evaluating-a-Cognitively
Citation Daniel K. Davies, Steven E. Stock, Larry R. King, Michael L. Wehmeyer, David Helm; “Moby-Dick Is My Favorite:” Evaluating a Cognitively Accessible Portable Reading System for Audiobooks for Individuals With Intellectual Disability. Intellect Dev Disabil 1 August 2008; 46 (4): 290–298. doi: https://doi-org.ezproxy.csu.edu.au/10.1352/1934-9556(2008)46[290:MIMFEA]2.0.CO;2

Summary of Key Information

Who? (participants) 49 participants (ave age 28.47yrs) with intellectual disabilities from local edu transition programs & adults receiving support
What? (program/ method) Use of three different reading software programs
Why? (problem/ question/ goal) Providing people with intellectual disabilities the opp to engage with print info
When? (year) 2008
Where? (context information) America
How? (what did the researcher use/ do?) 4 wk trial of reading assist prog

Data collected on two dependent measures

–       Accuracy

–       independence

Deeper analysis

Strengths
Weaknesses Age of article 2008

Only assisted in the setting

Age of participants (28.47)

Size of each group relatively small

Does not look at motivation or comprehension

Limitations/ questions raised for you How does software impact learning
Relation to other literature 9
Relation to my research/ area of interest Looks at software programs that may be used to assist with audiobks

 

 

  1. Article Source Information
Author(s) Milani, A., Lorusso, M. L., & Molteni, M.
Title The effects of audiobooks on the psychosocial adjustment of pre-adolescents and adolescents with dyslexia.
Year 2010
Search Information (Where and how did you find it? Google Scholar – Primo

“audiobook” AND “reading disability” AND school*

Link to article http://web.b.ebscohost.com.ezproxy.csu.edu.au/ehost/pdfviewer/pdfviewer?vid=1&sid=ecda6885-d75f-4cbc-93fb-5b89f031fd59%40pdc-v-sessmgr02
Citation Milani, A., Lorusso, M. L., & Molteni, M. (2010). The effects of audiobooks on the psychosocial adjustment of pre-adolescents and adolescents with dyslexia. Dyslexia (10769242), 16(1), 87–97. https://doi-org.ezproxy.csu.edu.au/10.1002/dys.397

Summary of Key Information

Who? (participants) K-5, LD
What? (program/ method) Looked at 70 articles (19 in the end) of K-5 students with LD

–       Target reading fluency in Eng

–       Experimental, quasi-exp, single subject with treatment & comparison

Why? (problem/ question/ goal) To investigate the effects of fluency interventions
When? (year) 2014
Where? (context information) America
How? (what did the researcher use/ do?) Synthesis of research on the effects of reading fluency & reading comprehension of K-5 with LD

Deeper analysis

Strengths Comprehensive study

Using audiobooks was effective to assist with repeated reading

 

Weaknesses More research needed for use of audiobks
Limitations/ questions raised for you Use of audiobks provides greater flexibility for teachers

Larger sample sizes required

Treatment duration

Relation to other literature 8
Relation to my research/ area of interest

 

 

  1. Article Source Information
Author(s) Elsa, T. M., Àngels Llanes Baró, & Garriga, À. P.
Title

Linguistic and non-linguistic outcomes of a reading-while-listening program for young learners of English

 

Year 2019
Search Information (Where and how did you find it? Primo

audiobooks AND EFL AND school*

Link to article https://search-proquest-com.ezproxy.csu.edu.au/docview/2076596753?accountid=10344&rfr_id=info%3Axri%2Fsid%3Aprimo
Citation Elsa, T. M., Àngels Llanes Baró, & Garriga, À. P. (2019). Linguistic and non-linguistic outcomes of a reading-while-listening program for young learners of english. Reading and Writing, 32(3), 819-838. doi:http://dx.doi.org.ezproxy.csu.edu.au/10.1007/s11145-018-9886-x

Summary of Key Information

Who? (participants) 25 students from four classes

Ages 10-11

What? (program/ method) Reading/listening of graded readers

Pre & post test

18 sessions over 2 days per week

21 graded readers total

Why? (problem/ question/ goal) To see if RWL improves students test results for literacy
When? (year) 2018/19
Where? (context information) Spain
How? (what did the researcher use/ do?) 18 sessions or RWL v RO

Deeper analysis

Strengths
Weaknesses Only 18 session of RWL or RO

Graded readers were short

Limitations/ questions raised for you Does student selection of bks impact
Relation to other literature
Relation to my research/ area of interest

 

 

  1. Article Source Information
Author(s) Chang, A., & Millett, S.
Title  

Improving reading rates and comprehension through audio-assisted extensive reading for beginner learners

 

Year 2015
Search Information (Where and how did you find it? Bibliographic branching
Link to article https://doi.org/10.1016/j.system.2015.05.003
Citation Chang, A., & Millett, S. (2015). Improving reading rates and comprehension through audio-assisted extensive reading for beginner learners. System, 52, 91-102. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.system.2015.05.003

Summary of Key Information

Who? (participants) 64 Yr 10 EFL students
What? (program/ method) SSR or AR over 26 wk pd for 90mins/wk
Why? (problem/ question/ goal) Effect of AR on reading rates & comprehension
When? (year) 2015
Where? (context information) Taiwan
How? (what did the researcher use/ do?) Pre test, post test, 3mnth delayed post test

Extensive reading program over 26wks

Deeper analysis

Strengths Loner time pd

Number of students 64

Weaknesses No control group

Researchers book choice

Need more texts and different types of text

Limitations/ questions raised for you
Relation to other literature 5
Relation to my research/ area of interest

 

 

  1. Article Source Information
Author(s) Nees, M., & Berry, L.
Title Audio assistive technology and accommodations for students with visual impairments: Potentials and problems for delivering curricula and educational assessments.
Year 2013
Search Information (Where and how did you find it? Bibliographic branching
Link to article https://doi.org/10.1016/j.peh.2013.08.016
Citation Nees, M., & Berry, L. (2013). Audio assistive technology and accommodations for students with visual impairments: Potentials and problems for delivering curricula and educational assessments. Performance Enhancement & Health, 2(3), 101-109. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.peh.2013.08.016

Summary of Key Information

Who? (participants)
What? (program/ method) Review of current practises and problems
Why? (problem/ question/ goal)
When? (year)
Where? (context information)
How? (what did the researcher use/ do?)

Deeper analysis

Strengths
Weaknesses
Limitations/ questions raised for you
Relation to other literature
Relation to my research/ area of interest

 

 

 

  1. Article Source Information
Author(s) Chang, A.
Title The effect of Reading While Listening to Audiobooks: Listening Fluency and Vocabulary Gain
Year 2011
Search Information (Where and how did you find it? Google Scholar
Link to article https://www.dyslexicadvantage.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/10/Reading-While-Listening.pdf
Citation Chang, A. (2011). The Effect of Reading While Listening to Audiobooks: Listening Fluency and Vocabulary Gain. Asian Journal of English Language Teaching, 21.

Summary of Key Information

Who? (participants) 19 students
What? (program/ method)
Why? (problem/ question/ goal) Effects of RWL on EFL fluency and voc gain
When? (year) 2011
Where? (context information) Taiwan
How? (what did the researcher use/ do?) 26 weeks intervention

Deeper analysis

Strengths
Weaknesses More and longer trials required.
Limitations/ questions raised for you
Relation to other literature
Relation to my research/ area of interest

 

 

 

EER500: Introduction to Educational Research (202060)
Assignment
1 – Literature Analysis and Research Question (40%)

Formative Criteria SY US
Appropriate use of writing conventions. Is coherent, structured and of an acceptable standard of literacy. Lacks coherence, structure and/or has serious deficiencies in the quality of the writing.
Correct use of a reference list and correct in-text referencing techniques consistent with APA 7 referencing style. Referencing conforms to APA 7 referencing style.

And

At least 8 relevant scholarly sources have been cited.

Referencing is omitted, or does not conform to APA 7 referencing style.

And/ or

Fewer than 8 relevant scholarly sources have been cited.

 

Criterion One HD DI CR PS FL
4.25-5 3.75-4.2 3.25-3.7 2.5-3.2 <2.5
Identifies the topic and explains the significance.

 

5 marks

Identifies a novel research topic (i.e. an area which has not yet been addressed in the literature) by providing specific definitions partly taken from scholarly literature and adapted for the research context. Fully articulates personal relevance (personal, professional and/or practical).

 

Identifies a more specific (multiple secondary points may be considered, such as level, method, measure, etc.) research topic by providing specific definitions taken from scholarly literature. Articulates personal relevance (personal, professional and/or practical). Identifies a specific (secondary points may be considered, such as level, method, measure, etc.) research topic by providing general definitions partly taken from scholarly literature. Partially articulates relevance (personal, professional and/or practical). Identifies a relatively broad, yet acceptable area for the proposed research. Partially outlines relevance (personal, professional and/or practical).

 

Does not meet pass criteria – See commentary for specific details

 

Criterion Two HD DI CR PS FL
8.5-10 7.5-8.4 6.5-7.4 5-6.4 <4.9
Outlines the scope of the review, identifies search terms employed and key literature sources

 

10 marks

Comprehensive level of description (e.g. what, when, why, reflection).

Employs at least three or more scholarly search approaches.

 

 

More than 15 combinations of search terms and search approaches are described.

 

A narrative structure is enriched by thoughtful and informed (e.g. reference to literature) reflection.

Strong level of description (e.g. what, when, why).

 

Employs at least three scholarly search approaches.

 

 

At least 15 combinations of search terms and search approaches are described.

 

A narrative structure enriched by some reflection.

Sound level of description (e.g. what, when).

 

Employs at least two scholarly search approaches.

 

At least 10 combinations of search terms and search approaches are described.

 

A narrative structure is introduced.

Basic level of description (e.g. what).

 

Employs at least one scholarly search approach.

 

 

At least 5 combinations of search terms and search approaches are described.

Does not meet pass criteria – See commentary for specific details

 

Criterion Three HD DI CR PS FL
12.75-15 11.25-12.6 9.75-11.1 7.5-9.6 <7.5
Presents an analysis and critique of prior literature

 

Displays knowledge of research design including theoretical framework/methodology and methods employed in key studies in the literature

 

15 marks

12 or more topic-relevant scholarly sources are reviewed deeply.

 

Describes specific trends broad trends with sophisticated description (specific paradigms, methods and techniques are presented) of research in a relational way (purpose, methods and findings are synthesised). Unpacks and critiques some evidence. The structure is refined and an overarching narrative structure is evident, connectives are used.

 

The textbook, additional subject readings and wider readings are drawn on for nuanced, critical discussion of methods.

 

Shows a sophisticated, nuanced understanding of the many aspects of research methods and paradigms. Draws on secondary elements where appropriate (samples, contexts, etc.). Informed comparisons are made. Multiple sources may be grouped to make larger critical points.

At least 10 topic-relevant scholarly sources are reviewed deeply.

 

Describes specific trends with sound description (key language is used with accuracy, deeper concepts may also be included) of research in a relational way (purpose, methods and findings are addressed together). Unpacks evidence. The structure is clear and generally logical, connectives are used.

 

 

The textbook, additional subject readings and wider readings are drawn on for meaningful, critical discussion of methods.

 

Shows a well-developed understanding of research methods and paradigms. Draws on secondary elements where appropriate (samples, contexts, etc.). Informed comparisons are made.

At least 8 topic-relevant scholarly sources are reviewed deeply.

 

Describes broad trends with sound description of research (key language is used with accuracy). The structure is clear and generally logical.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The textbook and additional subject readings are drawn on for meaningful discussion of methods.

 

Provides robust description of the fundamental aspects of research methods and paradigms. Draws on secondary elements where appropriate (samples, contexts, etc.). A critical tone is evident.

At least 6 topic-relevant scholarly sources are reviewed deeply.

 

Describes broad trends within the research with some description of research (some informal language may still be evident). The structure is sound but could be refined (some repetition and evidence without purpose may be evident).

 

 

 

 

 

The textbook is drawn on for meaningful discussion of methods.

 

 

 

Provides accurate description of the fundamental aspects of research methods and paradigms. Some critique is attempted.

 

Does not meet pass criteria – See commentary for specific details

 

 

 

Criterion Four HD DI CR PS FL
4.25-5 3.75-4.2 3.25-3.7 2.5-3.2 <2.5
Adopts a critical stance by identifying gaps/ tensions/ problems/ oversights/ weaknesses in the literature.

 

5 marks

Gap(s) is/ are presented at the end of the review, prior to the question. The gaps are thoughtfully signposted and unpacked in the body of the review.

 

At least three meaningful additional gaps are cited (e.g. content, method, year, perspective, context, etc.).

Gap(s) is/are presented at the end of the review, prior to the question. The gaps are explicitly signposted and unpacked in the body of the review.

 

At least two meaningful additional gaps are cited (e.g. content, method, year, perspective, context, etc.).

Gap(s) is/are presented at the end of the review, prior to the question. The gaps are implicitly evident in the body of the review.

 

 

At least one meaningful additional gap is cited (e.g. content, method, year, perspective, context, etc.).

Gap(s) is/are presented at the end of the review, prior to the question.

 

 

 

 

At least one meaningful gap in the knowledge domain is cited.

Does not meet pass criteria – See commentary for specific details

 

Criterion Five HD DI CR PS FL
4.25-5 3.75-4.2 3.25-3.7 2.5-3.2 <2.5
Produces a relevant research question to address in the research proposal (A2).

 

5 marks

Presents a sophisticated, nuanced research question alluding to a robust research approach in A2. The question clearly relates to a specific aspect of the topic through the gap(s) noted. Stakeholder(s) and construct(s) are fully described. There is a clear argument for the unique contribution to the literature. Presents a well-structured research question alluding to specific paradigm or method. The question relates to a specific aspect of the topic through the gap(s) noted. Stakeholder(s) and construct(s) are fully described. There is evidence of a unique contribution to the literature.

 

Presents an appropriately structured research question alluding to specific paradigm or method. The question relates to the main topic through the gap(s) noted. Stakeholder(s) and construct(s) are partially described. There is some evidence of a unique contribution to the literature.

 

Presents an appropriately structured research question. The question relates broadly to the main topic. Stakeholder(s) and construct(s) are presented.

 

 

 

Does not meet pass criteria – See commentary for specific details

 

 

 

Marking Rubric for Students (see above for more detailed information)

A1: Literature Review (40%) Value Mark
Use of academic language conventions SY/UN SY
Adherence to APA 7th referencing conventions SY/UN SY
Identifies the topic and explains the significance 5 3.5
Scope of the review process 10 9
Critique of prior literature and understanding of research paradigms and methods 15 13
Identification of Gaps in the literature 5 5
Presentation of research question for A2 5 4.5
TOTAL 40 35

 

Mark out of 40: 35                           Percentage:  87.5%                                          Grade:  High Distinction                              

 

Marker: Dr James Deehan

 

Please follow this link to access your audio feedback – https://drive.google.com/file/d/1WznyjZYQW95EwaIDtEO8364LbRddvumj/view?usp=sharing

Important note: Be sure to download the file to your computer by clicking on the icon in the top right corner of your browser.

 

 

Posted in EER 500 | Tagged | Leave a comment

Professional Placement Report.

Section 1: The placement organisation.

Inner West Libraries (IWL) provides a comprehensive service to a large and diverse range of individuals and groups in the Inner West local government area. IWL had over 96,000 registered members 2018-2019 (State Library of New South Wales, 2020), with the opening of the new Marrickville Library on the 31st of August 2019 the number of members was expected to be much higher for 2019-2020, however with the increase in demand for services due to COVID-19 the number of members is now expected to be over 100,000 (A. Mullen, personal communication, August 3rd, 2020). IWL provides library services across eight branches within the Inner West Council area: Ashfield, Balmain, Haberfield, Leichhardt, Marrickville, Stanmore, St Peters/Sydenham and the Council’s historical archive centre in Petersham. IWL is a part of the Inner West Council and works towards meeting the needs of Inner West Residents through following the vision of the council:

We are the Inner West, land of the Gadigal and Wangal peoples, whose rich cultures, heritage and history we acknowledge and respect. We are defined by our diversity of people, places and ideas. We are an inclusive, vibrant, caring and progressive community where everyone is welcome, people and nature live in harmony and creativity is a way of life” (Inner West Council, 2018).

IWL provides a wide range of information services to meet the needs of a diverse range of stakeholders who are a part of the vibrant community of the Inner West. IWL provides services, programs and events to engage and inform patrons including collections in multiple languages and genres to meet the multicultural needs of individuals that reside in the community. For example Ashfield library has a dedicated Chinese collection, Leichhardt an Italian collection and Marrickville has a diverse LGBTIQ collection. IWL also assists individuals who find it difficult to physically visit the library by providing an extensive home library service. The libraries also have a dedicated History department, which assists individuals to research family and house history, access Council archives and promote cultural collections and exhibitions. All IWL have free WiFi and computer access, dedicated study areas and provide a wide range of programs tailored to the local communities in which they reside with programs available for babies through to retirees.  Through their work with local communities, IWL are able to successfully meet the key goals of public libraries as set out by the Australian Library and Information Association (2018) by promoting Australian writers and creators through author talks and writing competitions for youth; providing safe spaces for study, work and relaxation and ensuring freedom of access to the information.

The importance of IWL as part of the community was highlighted during the COVID-19 lockdown. Due to the lockdown, a large number of the community were unable to access essential services, which are readily available through IWL including computer and internet access, young and youth programs as well as reading materials. The IWL experienced a high increase in the number of phone and email enquiries from patrons in need of the everyday services that IWL provide. In response to the increasing number of enquiries per day, IWL management team proactively put in place services to assist the community to access services which would normally be available within the physical library. A “click and collect” option for patrons was trialled to allow access to the physical resources of the library, patrons were able to request books through an online library, books were borrowed out the patrons and available to be picked up outside the library; the use of this service allows patrons to access library resources and again engage with the collection. A number of other high demand services were also produced digitally and made available online; this demonstrated the adaptability of library staff, most of whom had not used the technology required to make online content; some of the most demanded services produced were storytime and book buddies for young children, all services were well received by the community and still utilised after partial reopening.

Section 2: Theory into practice ETL503

Whilst undertaking my placement with IWL, I spent time with the library collections coordinator. This was especially relevant to my learning, I find resourcing the collection one of the most challenging aspects to the role of Teacher Librarian; ensuring that the collection of the school library is relevant, accessible and up to date for our school community. ETL 503 Resourcing the Curriculum allowed the development of my knowledge regarding the importance of having a well-structured, proactive and adaptable collection development policy for the library to follow. A collection development policy is a significant library document that is essential to a school library as it explains why the library exists, it reflects the library’s mission and the intentions for building its collections collaboratively. As with a school library, the IWL collections coordinator must develop and implement a collection development policy which meets the missions, goals and objectives of the library and the wider community where each library is located (Australian Library and Information Association School & Victorian Catholic Teacher Librarians. 2017). Implementing a collection development policy is important for both school and public libraries to ensure the need requirements of the community are the driving force for selection and to ensure that the library collection supports the goals, programs and interests of patrons through resources, technology and space. (Hughes-Hassel & Mansell, 2005; National Library of New Zealand, n.d.)

Within a school library it is the professional responsibility of the Teacher Librarian in collaboration with teachers and students to provide the informational, instructional and recreational reading resources that meet the needs of the school community (Church, 2017). Within a public library it is the professional responsibility of the informational specialist in the role of collections coordinator to work closely with branch managers to ensure the needs of the patrons and communities of the individual libraries is met. Within each of the IWL there is a specialist collection, as discussed in Section 1, which must be resourced through the collection development policy and it is essential the collections coordinator works closely with the branch manager and the community to ensure the specialist collection is relevant to the needs of the community. Patron Driven Acquisition (American Library Association, 2014; Swords, 2011) is also used by IWL to meet the needs of the community; this has also led to greater technology access within the library and the collection with audio and eBooks. Patrons have driven this change to greater availability of technological resources within IWL (K. Dwarte, personal communication, August 4th, 2020). IWL have also recently placed its catalogue online, to allow patrons to click and collect physical resources; greater online content and placing the catalogue online was a long term goal of IWL, however due to the impacts of COVID-19, this was highlighted as a requirement by the IWL communities and has been proactively incorporated this year after community consultation to meet patron and community needs during the Sydney lockdown. Patron Driven Acquisition in both school and public libraries allows greater collaboration between the information specialists and the community in which the library operates; collaboration and support leads to interconnectedness of the library and the community (Mardis, 2016) and assists in meeting the needs of the community and ultimately the goals of the library.

The IWL collections coordinator is presently writing a collection development policy for a new music library which will be located at Ashfield. I was able to see first-hand the steps the coordinator undertakes in ensuring the music library is needed in the community as well as being successfully resourced to meet the identified needs within the community. Extensive collaboration has taken place with the collections coordinator, individual branch managers, musical instrument suppliers and the community to ensure the music library will be resourced with instruments that meet patrons’ needs, while also being of high quality. The collections coordinator is using the information gained through this consultation to ensure the music library is relevant and accessible for the community. I found being a part of the process of writing the music library collection development policy invaluable to my continued learning of writing a policy, as it allowed me to use the theoretical knowledge gained from ETL503 in practice. This experience further cemented the need for a well-written collection development policy as it is an advocacy tool for the Teacher Librarian, as it is for IWL, and proves the value of not only the library collection but also the value of the Teacher Librarian as the informational professional. I now feel more confident in my knowledge and understanding of the procedures in planning and writing collection development policies and will be able to use the knowledge gained and adapt the procedures and skills used with IWL to my high school library situation.

Section 3: Critical reflection

I honestly feel like one of the luckiest people in the world to have been allowed the opportunity to undertake my Professional Placement with Inner West Libraries (IWL), especially with COVID-19 lockdowns and cases continuing to pop up around the Inner West areas. I was excited to be able to complete a physical placement after completing Virtual Study Visits and having my eyes opened to the opportunities that the Master of Teacher Librarianship can provide for me with future career options. Whilst being a frequent visitor of public libraries, I had very little understanding of the full gamut of services offered by public libraries or the management of such a diverse range of public libraries such as those that are a part of the Inner West Library group.

Whilst on placement, I was able to visit each of the IWL which were open during the time of my placement; a number of the smaller libraries are still closed due to COVID-19 restrictions. Each library has its own specialist area as well as diversity in the library services and resources provided due to patron identified needs and community background of the area in which the library is located. I was able to meet with the branch manager of each library as well as specialists who were located in each branch, everyone was very accommodating and generous with their time especially given their increased and varied workloads brought about due to restrictions within the libraries and the services which can be provided physically and online.

Marrickville Library is the newest library within the IWL group. The library is a three storey purpose built building which was originally a hospital, throughout construction, heritage elements of the main hospital building has been conserved and the library has recently been awarded four separate architectural awards (Mirvac, 2020), working in this space was exciting and I will consider how I can better manage my library space to make it more inviting and usable for students, staff and our wider community. I was able to work closely with a number of key team members from IWL including:

  • Senior Management – this was interesting to gain an overall understanding of IWL and the day to day operations which have to take place in order for the effective management of the libraries, this was especially important for me as I move into a role where I will be responsible for management of the school library and also a number of teams within the school. This provided me an understanding of management styles and how to motivate staff to meet the goals of the library, an interesting aspect of IWL is that staff spend two years in a library and then move to another library usually staff will move from a bigger library to a smaller library throughout the Inner West, this highlighted the need to be proactive with goal setting, time management and interpersonal skills to ensure that your time is used effectively to meet the needs of the patrons and the community during your time in an information specialist role.
  • Marketing – taking part in a public libraries marketing team meeting via Zoom was an invaluable experience into how public libraries use social media networks to connect with patrons and the wider community. I am responsible for the social media pages of our high school and the meeting provided new ideas and avenues I can use in the future for the school and to promote the resources and services the library provides.
  • Home Library Service (HLS) – this was a service I was unaware of, it provides a drop off service of the collection to vulnerable patrons; this service is very important for the patrons who access it and the HLS has become even more important during COVID-19 as more vulnerable individuals are unable to physically visit the IWL.
  • Music Library – IWL is in the process of adding a musical instrument library to the Ashfield collection, presently the manager of Ashfield library is in the process of deciding which instruments to include in the collection based on patron requests, sourcing instruments and the borrowing and returns process for the instruments. This highlighted the importance of listening to patrons and meeting the needs of the community.

As with the virtual study visits, this professional placement has provided me with a greater understanding of the large number of exciting career opportunities that are available to information specialists. I am now excited by further employment opportunities outside of the school setting that the Master of Teacher Librarianship can ultimately provide, as well as areas of further study which complement this degree.

References

American Library Association. (2014). Keeping up with… patron driven acquisitions.

http://www.ala.org/acrl/publications/keeping_up_with/pda

 

Australian Library and Information Association. (2018). Statement on public library services. https://www.alia.org.au/about-alia/policies-standards-and-guidelines/statement-public-library-services#:~:text=Public%20libraries%20are%20agile%20and,heritage%3B%20cybersafety%20and%20digital%20inclusion.&text=They%20jointly%20advocate%20for%20the,state%20and%20national%20government%20priorities.

Australian Library and Information Association School & Victorian Catholic Teacher Librarians. (2017). A manual for developing policies and procedures in Australian school library resource centers. [Template]. Retrieved from: https://asla.org.au/resources/Documents/Website%20Documents/Policies/policies-procedures-manual_ed2.pdf

Hughes-Hassell, S. & Mancall, J. (2005). Collection management for youth: responding to the needs of learners [ALA Editions version]. http://ebookcentral.proquest.com.ezproxy.csu.edu.au/lib/csuau/detail.action?docID=289075

 

Inner West Council. (2018). Our Inner West 2036 – Community Strategic Plan. https://www.innerwest.nsw.gov.au/about/the-council/corporate-planning-performance-budget/our-inner-west-2036-community-strategic-plan/community-strategic-plan

 

Mardis, M. A. (Ed.). (2016). Librarians and educators collaborating for success: The international perspective. https://ebookcentral.proquest.com

 

Mirvac. (2020, July 8). Designed by BVN, delivered by Mirvac and Inner West Council, loved by all. https://marrickandco.mirvac.com/news-and-events/News/2020/marrickville-library-award

 

National Library of New Zealand (n.d.). Selecting and purchasing resources. https://natlib.govt.nz/schools/school-libraries/collections-and-resources/selecting-resources-for-your-collection/selecting-and-purchasing-resources

 

State Library of New South Wales (2020). Public Library Statistics 2018–19. https://www.sl.nsw.gov.au/sites/default/files/5569_public_library_statistics_2018-19_final_text_pi-89_aw_0.pdf

Posted in ETL 507 | Tagged | Leave a comment

Virtual Study Visits Blog Post: What role does technology play in the relationship information agencies develop with their users?

ETL 507 – Blog Post: What role does technology play in the relationship information agencies develop with their users?

 

The provision of access to information is the core mission of all libraries and information agencies (Garrudi & Wyber, 2019, p. 17). Technology plays an essential role in allowing information agencies to access, store and provide information for patrons, the wider community and future generations. Technology provided by libraries and information agencies also allows patrons to acquire and develop 21st Century skills and assists in bridging inequalities and the digital divide, which often occurs within and between communities (Subramaniam & Braun, 2020; National and State Libraries Australasia, 2017).  Within various settings, the importance of technology has been highly visible in the day to day working of the information agency and has been essential during the present pandemic.

 

A large number of information specialists discussed the importance of technology within their roles and how technology can assist not only their patrons but also their communities and future generations. S. Turbitt (personal communication, May 6, 2020) discussed how important technology was in her role at the University of Newcastle Maker Space. She stated that within the role technology is essential for students and staff at the university to develop transferable 21st Century skills in the digital space. The Maker Space is a non-academic area, where technology is available for patrons to experiment, create, collaborate and problem solve while using technology. S. Turbitt  (personal communication, May 6, 2020) and R. Manuell (personal communication, May 11, 2020) engage their communities through excitement with using technology, preempting the needs of lecturers and collaborating with ‘technology champions’ in faculties to educate people about the work they do and to encourage greater use of the areas by university staff, students and faculties.

 

G. Steele (personal communication, May 12, 2020) and K. James (personal communication, May 6, 2020) utilise technology to preserve culturally significant historical items to ensure that they are available for present patrons and future generations (State Library of NSW 2019, p.55). Technology has assisted in the process of preserving items as well as the speed at which work can take place; technology allows storage & sharing of resources, elimination of duplication and ultimately improves the quality of information (Arun Kumara, Shilpa and Santhosh Kumar, 2018). Affordable digital equipment and state of the art, newly developed software is used by the information specialists to assist in the storage of significant cultural items, which would possibly be lost to communities and future generations if this technology was not available. K. James (personal communication, May 6, 2020) also highlighted the importance of technology for less developed nations in the Pacific and also remote Aboriginal communities where she worked in collaboration with these communities to preserve their history by using technology.  Digitisation of the material assists in marketing the information agencies core work, while providing fair and equitable access to culturally and historically significant information and items. Technology assists in making collections visible and demonstrates the worth of the Pacific Manuscripts Bureau and Museums Victoria Library & Archives collections.

 

The use of social media as a technological tool to engage and inform patrons and communities was also discussed by a number of information agencies (I. Tucker, personal communication, May 13, 2020; G. Steele, personal communication, May 12, 2020; L. Korodaj, personal communication, May 13, 2020). The use of Twitter, Facebook and Instagram is often used to inform communities and patrons of the essential work and services provided by information agencies. The onset of Covid-19 led to increased use of technology not only for information agencies to continue their invaluable work at home, but also to allow patrons access to  services provided by libraries and information agencies. Information agencies had to quickly adapt to a rapidly changing environment where patrons were no longer able to physically access their services, yet still provide equity and accessibility to patrons (Farkas, 2016, p. 31; Arun Kumara, Shilpa and Santhosh Kumar, 2018); technology was the key to ensuring patrons were still able to have questions answered and ready access to collections. R. Manuell (personal communication, May 11, 2020) discussed how online drop-in centres, chat bots and other technology was integrated to ensure that patrons at Monash University were provided with information to assist in the completion of their degrees while the library was closed. G. Steele (personal communication, May 12, 2020) and I. Tucker (personal communication, May 13, 2020) also stated that technology was essential to continue to engage with patrons during the closure of libraries.

 

Technology has been used in various ways including online access of collections, greater access to alternate digital subscriptions, online book clubs and digital assistance to patrons. Information agencies have used technology to creatively engage patrons during Covid-19 to ensure users are able to connect to information specialist services at any time, anywhere and remain socially connected with their communities (I. Tucker, personal communication, May 13, 2020). The changing nature of libraries, particularly during the Covid-19 pandemic, was reflected through the Gympie library’s face shield initiative (Gympie Regional Library, 2020). The library used their technology resources following a public request for assistance with providing medical staff with adequate protective face shields by Queensland Health. This flexibility and adaptation of library resources to meet the needs of the community has been a recurring theme throughout the rapidly emerging technological era.

 

Technology is also used by information specialists to record data about collections and borrowers. R. Manuell (personal communication, May 11, 2020) and G. Steele (personal communication, May 12, 2020) use technology to assist with benchmarking against other libraries. Technology is also a digital networking tool for the information specialist to advance their careers and make their work more visible; the use of Twitter by G. Steele (personal communication, May 12, 2020) has promoted her profile not only through greater engagement with colleagues but also the wider information specialist community, where she has been invited to to take part in events and conferences all brought about through her digital presence with Twitter. Platforms such as Yammer, a collaborative online environment developed by Microsoft, create opportunities to improve communication, gather ideas and provide feedback (Yammer, 2020). This is particularly important within information agencies as often they are pioneering ideas and technology and introducing these in an engaging way that encourages users who may be reluctant or fearful of technology. Throughout the Covid-19 pandemic, a virtual staffroom that linked Teacher Librarians was established, largely focussed on ways to guide and support patrons through the introduction of virtual classrooms. This included the collection and provision of online resources and way to support productive relationships between libraries and users, as well as teachers and students.

 

Ultimately technology allows information specialists to build strong relationships with their patrons and make collections equitably available and better; not only for present patrons of the information agency, but also ensuring that the agency evolves with society to ensure they meet the demands of current patrons, while also ensuring that culturally and historically significant items are preserved for the future and future generations.

 

References

Arun Kumara, T., Shilpa, B. & Santhosh Kumar, K. (2018). ICT application to next

generation libraries. Journal of Advances in Library and Information Science, 7(3), 227-231.

Retrieved from http://jalis.in/pdf/7-3/Arun.pdf

 

Farkas, M. (2016). In practice: The new digital divide. American Libraries, 47(1/2), 31-31. Retrieved from  www.jstor.org/stable/24604202

 

Garrido, M. & Wyber, S. (eds.). (2019). Development and access to information. International  Federation of Library Associations and Institutions. Retrieved from https://da2i.ifla.org/wp-content/uploads/da2i-2019-full-report.pdf

 

Gympie Regional Library. (2020). Gympie library using technology to fight covid-19. Retrieved from https://www.gympie.qld.gov.au/news-events/-/asset_publisher/fwAja6773ctR/content/gympie-library-using-technology-to-help-fight-covid-19?redirect=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.gympie.qld.gov.au%2Fnews-events%3Fp_p_id%3D101_INSTANCE_fwAja6773ctR%26p_p_lifecycle%3D0%26p_p_state%3Dnormal%26p_p_mode%3Dview%26p_p_col_id%3Dcolumn-2%26p_p_col_pos%3D1%26p_p_col_count%3D3

 

National and State Libraries Australasia (2017). Libraries and digital government: Collaborating to build digital citizenship. Retrieved from https://www.nsla.org.au/sites/default/files/documents/nsla.libraries-digital-government_sept17.pdf

 

State Library of NSW (2019). Library council of NSW 2018-2019 annual report. Retrieved from https://www.sl.nsw.gov.au/sites/default/files/5384_libraryannreport_webaccess_13022020.pdf

 

Subramaniam, M., & Braun, L. (2020). COVID-19 is an opportunity to rethink youth librarianship: Reimagining libraries. School Library Journal. Retrieved from https://www.slj.com/?detailStory=covid-19-is-an-opportunity-to-rethink-youth-librarianship-reimagining-libraries

 

Yammer. (2020). Yammer overview. Retrieved from https://www.microsoft.com/en-au/microsoft-365/yammer/yammer-overview

Virtual Study Visit Reflection

 

After being initially apprehensive about undertaking the Sydney study visits due to my large workload and failure to see the connection between my role and the visits, my apprehension turned to excitement when the timetable for the visits were sent out. I had very little knowledge of some of the organisations on the list, and even less understanding of how the degree I was completing could provide the opportunity to work in such a diverse range of organisations.

 

Unfortunately, the Covid-19 pandemic put all study visits on hold and alternative arrangements had to be made, was I disappointed with the loss of physical visits – yes. However, we were then extremely lucky and privileged to have virtual study visits organised for us. The virtual study visits encompassed a  positive and diverse group of individuals employed in a vast array of information specialist roles.

 

Some of the highlights for me included:

 

  • Sally Turbitt at the Academic Library University of Newcastle – with her insights on how to engage people to be creative and curious through organising a space for opportunities, problem solving and collaboration.

  • Karrie James with Pacific Manuscripts at ANU – the various positions which Karrie has held during her career is truly inspirational and how her work is making historical pieces available for the future and future generations.

  • Gemma Steele Museums Victoria Library and Archives – Gemma’s role at the library was fascinating and the archives that she was able to show us were exceptional, again another information specialist area which I had not considered as an avenue through my learning.

 

While completing this degree as a requirement for my role as Teacher Librarian within the Department of Education I had not taken the time to consider further employment possibilities that the degree may lead to. Through the virtual study visits I have had my eyes opened to a large number of exciting career opportunities that are available to information specialists. I am now excited by the employment opportunities that the Master of Teacher Librarianship can ultimately provide, as well as areas of further study which complement this degree.

Posted in ETL 507 | Tagged | Leave a comment

ETL 402 – Reflections.

At the beginning of my ETL 402 journey, I will admit I had very little understanding of the difference between literacy learning and literary learning or the importance of selecting books to engage students in sustained enjoyable reading (Dunn, 2020a). This subject has allowed me to develop a very strong appreciation of the importance of literary learning across curriculum units to provide greater choices, to motivate students in their engagement with literacy and ultimately assisting students to learn ‘through’ literature. I noted it was important that educators are dealing with individuals who are reading in a vastly changed literature landscape and that the more ‘traditional’ reading of the past may not provide the same enjoyment and engagement with students of today (Dunn, 2020b).

I am now very excited to use the knowledge gained from assignment one to highlight the importance of various fiction collections within the library and how I can incorporated fiction into a variety of curriculum units. While assignment two has provided me with a greater understanding of the opportunities available to collaborate with classroom teachers and engage students with Literature Response Strategies within units of work. It is through our role as Teacher Librarians (TL) that we are able to provide relevant and engaging reading opportunities for students (Gibbons, 2020) as well as decreasing the anxiety of teachers of using technology with their classes; ultimately, through our role, we are able to bring new ideas about the use of technology and teaching strategies into the school (Dunn, 2020c).

I have already planned collaboratively with our HSIE faculty to implement the literary learning program, created for assignment two, with our Year 10 cohort when they are completing the depth study Rights and Freedoms 1945-present (ACARA, 2010) later this year. The students will be creating their own book bentos following the steps outlined in assignment two; this will involve collaboration between the HSIE faculty and myself. Collaboration will provide classroom teachers with a greater understanding of literary response strategies, use of historical fiction and non-fiction in the history classroom and the use of technology as a motivational and engagement strategy for students.

I am looking forward to spending more time developing further literary learning programs for our school and working collaboratively across curriculum areas to team teach units of work using a variety of literary response strategies. A large number of excellent examples literary response strategies have been highlighted in our discussion forums (Murphy, 2020; Templeton, 2020). It has been an exciting journey discovering new aspects of children’s and young adult’s literature which I had a limited understanding of; applying literature to new learning experiences for students to engage and motivate reading at our school and ultimately create the bibliophiles of the future.

 

References

 

Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority (ACARA) 2010, Year 10 content descriptions. Retrieved from Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority website: https://www.australiancurriculum.edu.au/f-10-curriculum/humanities-and-social-sciences/history/

 

Dunn, B (2020a, March 20). Childrens literature [Blog post]. Retrieved from https://thinkspace.csu.edu.au/bellid/2020/03/20/childrens-literature/

 

Dunn, B (2020b, March 6). The changing of the book [Blog post]. Retrieved from https://thinkspace.csu.edu.au/bellid/2020/03/06/the-changing-of-the-book/

 

Dunn, B (2020c, April 29). Re: 4.2 Reading from the screen [Online discussion comment]. Retrieved from Charles Sturt University website: https://interact2.csu.edu.au/webapps/discussionboard/do/message?action=list_messages&course_id=_44234_1&nav=discussion_board_entry&conf_id=_88815_1&forum_id=_181938_1&message_id=_2862910_1

 

Gibbons, S (2020, May 2). Re: 4.2 Reading from the screen [Online discussion comment]. Retrieved from Charles Sturt University website: https://interact2.csu.edu.au/webapps/discussionboard/do/message?action=list_messages&course_id=_44234_1&nav=discussion_board_entry&conf_id=_88815_1&forum_id=_181938_1&message_id=_2862910_1

 

Murphy, D (2020, May 14).  6.3 Literature Circles in History [Online discussion comment]. Retrieved from Charles Sturt University website: https://interact2.csu.edu.au/webapps/discussionboard/do/message?action=list_messages&course_id=_44234_1&nav=discussion_board_entry&conf_id=_88815_1&forum_id=_181940_1&message_id=_2937474_1

 

Templeton, T. (2020, May 10). Book Trailers – [Online discussion comment]. Retrieved from Charles Sturt University website: https://interact2.csu.edu.au/webapps/discussionboard/do/message?action=list_messages&course_id=_44234_1&nav=discussion_board_entry&conf_id=_88815_1&forum_id=_181940_1&message_id=_2920970_1

Posted in ETL 402 | Tagged | Leave a comment

ETL 402 – Assign 2

Literary Learning Program: Year 10 History – Rights and Freedoms.

 

Rational.

 

Providing students with high quality reading material creates literary development and motivates students to engage in more complex literature (Cornett, 2014). It is the role of the Teacher Librarian (TL) to curate and provide reading material that meets the learning and recreational needs of students; through their knowledge of children’s literature the TL will select appropriate titles which will increase student’s desire and ability to read (Akins, Tichenor, Heins, & Piechura, 2018). Literary learning occurs when literature is used to support and create meaningful learning in curriculum areas. This allows students to become active readers and develop higher order thinking skills through their engagement with texts; literary learning provides students with the opportunity to become evaluators, thinkers, creators and innovators through reading (Lamb & Johnson, 2010).

 

The use of historical fiction and non-fiction narratives in history classes can reinvigorate the subject and allow easier access for students to create connections, provoke inquiry and form a deeper understanding of the concepts which are traditionally covered in the history classroom and textbooks (Howell, 2014; Murdoch, 2015; Sliwak, 2008). Literary learning, through the use of engaging historical fiction and non-fiction narratives, assists in developing students’ understanding and perspective of historical events; and cultivates empathy for individuals and groups impacted from injustices of the past. Through the use of literary response strategies students develop critical and creative thinking skills such as critical reasoning, logic, resourcefulness, imagination and innovation (ACARA, 2010a); essential skills required for 21st Century learners.

 

The following resource kit has been curated to meet the needs of a mixed ability Year 10 NSW Department of Education History class focusing on the depth study Rights and Freedoms 1945-present (ACARA, 2010b). The class has a reading ability of 9-17 years, 8% of students identify as Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander and 4% of students are English as an Additional Language/Dialect. The use of historical fiction and non-fiction narratives within a history class will assist to address curriculum outcomes, provide alternative perspectives and create empathy for others. Collaboration between the Classroom Teacher (CT), a specialist in their subject, and the TL, a literary specialist, will lead to innovative lessons and greater engagement of students to ultimately learn through literature (Schwartzbach-Kang & Kang, 2019; Lamb & Johnson, 2010).

 

 

Resource List

Resource Number 1
Title The little red yellow black book: an introduction to indigenous Australia. (Fourth Edition)
Contributors Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies

Pascoe, B.

Genre Historical Fiction
Format Illustrated literary nonfiction novel
Publisher and Date Aboriginal Studies Press, 2018.
Annotation This book has been written from an Indigenous view point to provide an introduction and background to Aboriginal culture and heritage. The book is easily accessible to students and has a large number of illustrations throughout the book which will assist visual learners. This is the fourth edition of the highly popular book; it has the inclusion of significant contributions made by Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people across all aspects of Australian society. The book allows students to develop a strong understanding of the First Peoples culture and struggles they have faced since colonisation; including government policies which negatively impacted large numbers of individuals and communities. The recommended reading age of the book is upper secondary – 14 years (Education Services Australia, 2018).

 

 

 

 

 

Resource Number 2.
Title Sorry Day.
Author Vass, C.
Illustrator Leffler, D.
Genre Historical Fiction
Format Picture Book
Publisher and Date National Library of Australia, 2019.
Annotation Sorry Day illustrates the significance of the acknowledgement by then Prime Minister Kevin Rudd to the Aboriginal children and families of the Stolen Generation. The book is beautifully illustrated and with each page turn, readers are taken from the day of the Prime Minister’s speech to the history of the children being taken from their families. It is an important book that highlights the significance of saying sorry and acknowledging the pain brought about to individuals and families due to past government policies. The end of the book also provides further information regarding reconciliation and the importance of National Sorry Day being commemorated each year to remember and acknowledge the hurt caused to the Stolen Generation.

The book has received two literary awards and while having a reading age of 6-12 years (Pledger Consulting, 2020); the significance of the book makes it an important inclusion for students completing the Rights and Freedoms Year 10 History depth study (ACARA, 2010b).

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Resource Number 3.
Title Young Dark Emu: A truer history.
Author Pascoe, B.
Genre Historical Fiction.
Format Sophisticated Picture Book.
Publisher and Date Magalaba Books, 2019.
Annotation Young Dark Emu: A truer history is a junior version of the multi award winning Dark Emu novel. This sophisticated picture book provides readers with an alternative history of how Indigenous Australians lived pre-European colonisation. The book includes a large number of illustrations of historic value, including first hand diary entries, sketches and accounts from early colonist’s first contact with Indigenous Australians. The way that the book is organised, with the inclusion of headings and pictures throughout, entices young readers to further explore historical facts and information about Australia’s First Nations People. Young Dark Emu: A truer history has been shortlisted for four separate awards in 2020; proving the importance of this nonfiction narrative text for inclusion in a study of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander history. The book has a reading range of 9-14 years (Pledger Consulting, 2020).

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Resource Number 4.
Title Took the Children Away.
Author Roach, A.
Illustrator Hudson, P.

Hunter, R.

Genre Historical Fiction
Format Sophisticated Picture Book
Publisher and Date One Day Hill Publishers, 2010.
Annotation This sophisticated picture book is a visual representation of the dual ARIA and international Human Rights Achievement award winning song by the same name. Archie Roach is a member of the Stolen Generation and is a strong advocate for Aboriginal and Human Rights. The book is inspirationally illustrated throughout to guide the reader through the story of the impact of Aboriginal children being forcibly removed from their families as a result of government policy 1910 – 1970. There are also stunning landscape paintings of the author’s traditional homelands. The book has a reading range of 8-12 years (Pledger Consulting, 2020).

 

 

 

 

Resource Number 5.
Title Growing up Aboriginal in Australia.
Author Heiss, A. [Editor]
Genre Autobiography
Format Literary Nonfiction Anthology
Publisher and Date Black Inc., 2018
Annotation This book is a collection of nonfiction stories from a diverse range of Aboriginal authors from all over Australia, including the stories of high profile individuals, elders and youth. Each memoir provides a background of the individual’s life and upbringing; and how they have been treated in the wider community. As each story is relatively short, it benefits students who may have difficulty engaging in longer or more complex readings. There are a number of stories related to the Stolen Generation which would specifically assist with the depth study of Rights and Freedoms (ACARA, 2010b). The book has a reading range of 14-18 years (Pledger Consulting, 2020).

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Resource Number 6.
Title Who Am I? [the diary of Mary Talence, Sydney, 1937]
Author Anita Heiss
Genre Historical Fiction
Format Novel – Diary Entry
Publisher and Date Omnibus Books, 2020
Annotation This powerful story details a year in the life of a fictional Stolen Generation child. It is written in a diary format and guides readers through her everyday life activities, thoughts and dreams. It is a poignant look at the impact of the removal of Indigenous children from their families to assimilate them into white society. The book is very easy to read; allowing students to develop empathy and a deep understanding of the daily life of children who were a part of the Stolen Generation. Anita Heiss is an award winning author and member of the Wiradjuri Nation. A large number of historical records and resources were used in the writing of this fictional novel; in an attempt to provide a realistic view of the time period and impacts government policy on Aboriginal people. The book has a reading range of 11-14 years (Pledger Consulting, 2020).

 

Resource Number 7.
Title Twelve Canoes.
Author De Heer, R. and the Yolngu People of Ramingining
Retrieved from https://www.12canoes.com.au/
Genre Documentary
Format Website
Publisher and Date 2008, Indigemedia Incorporated.
Annotation Ramingining is a small and remote Aboriginal community in the Northern part of Central Arnhem Land. Rolf de Meer and the Yolngu People of Ramingining have worked together to create an immersive digital experience which reveals the First Peoples culture and present day lives. The experience is based around twelve visual short stories and allows viewers to learn about the Yolngu Peoples culture, history and homelands. Each short story also provides extras which provide further information related to the story viewed. Our Ancestors, First White People and Thomson Time are directly related to the depth study of Rights and Freedom (ACARA, 2010), however all stories assist in the development of empathy and understanding of the First Nations Peoples. Due to the nature of the resource, it would be accessible to a large age range.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Literature Response Strategies.

 

  1. Book Bento.

A book bento is a multimodal strategy that can enhance a student’s response to literature through creative means (Bales, 2018; Victoria State Government, 2019). Students select significant items related to a text and provide reasoning behind the inclusion of the items into their book bento. Creation of a book bento allows students to personally express their ideas and thoughts about a given text. Students will be creating their book bento using the digital tool Thinglink to produce and present their book bento; using technology leads to greater motivation and engagement of 21st Century learners (Francis, 2017).

 

Procedures:

 

  • The TL will provide the CT and Student Learning Support Officer (SLSO) with in depth information about the use of book bentos as a literary response strategy, examples of book bentos will be provided as well as training in the use of Thinglink; the program which will be used by students to create their book bentos.
  • The TL will work with the CT and SLSO to select four texts which are accessible to the class. The following texts will be included: Sorry Day (Vass, 2019), Young Dark Emu: A truer history (Pascoe, 2019), Who Am I? [the diary of Mary Talence] (Heiss, 2020) and Took the Children Away (Roach, 2010). These books have been specifically selected to meet the outcomes related to:
    1. Background to the struggle of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples for rights and freedoms before 1965, including the Stolen Generation (ACARA, 2010b)
    2. The significance of the following for the civil rights of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples: the Apology (ACARA, 2010b).
  • The TL, with their specialist knowledge of children’s literature will assist students select an appropriate text which will increase their desire to read and complete the activity (Akins, Tichenor, Heins, & Piechura, 2018). Students read their selected texts and make notes on interesting information they have discovered from the text.
  • Students are introduced to the concept of book bentos, shown examples of book bentos and introduced to the program Thinglink.
  • Explicit information is provided to students regarding copyright and the ethical use of music, pictures and book covers; students will be encouraged to use Creative Commons to access media and will be shown the correct way to acknowledge sources used (State of NSW, 2020). Discussion will take place in regards to gaining permission to use other peoples work such as book covers, it will be explained to the class that the TL has gained permission to use the covers from each publisher.
  • Students will create their book bento and provide explanation to the reasoning of inclusion of each item, leading to the development of higher order and critical thinking skills (Collins, 2014).
  • Students will peer review two other students’ book bentos; peer reviewing enhances students’ learning, promotes reflection, provides valuable feedback and creates positive learning environments (Jisc, 2015). Once feedback has been received students can review their work and make changes as required.
  • Students’ work will be displayed within the library to showcase the students’ understanding of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples struggle for rights and freedoms.
  • For support and instructions of how book bento boxes can be implemented in the classroom read: Highfill, L & Kloos, R. (2018). #BookBento HyperDoc Original. Retrieved from https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1FggkSwPyKx4YW1VlD9UB1b9FbfDBdQvEz93D2JgYUl4/edit#slide=id.p this article provides an in depth, practical guide for creating book bentos including using Thinglink.
  • For further information related to the pedagogical benefits of book bentos read: Bales, J. & Saint-John, L. (2020). ‘Book bento boxes: Creative reading response’, Scan, 39(3). This article provides detailed information on book bentos as a literary learning tool which creates meaning through reading and multimodal expression.
  1. Digital Storytelling

Digital storytelling is a multimodal approach to sharing a narrative (Wyman, 2020). Students are using digital tools in their everyday lives to create and produce personal digital stories through a variety of social media sites such as TikTok and Instagram (Lorenz, 2019). Using digital storytelling as a literary response strategy promotes and motivates student learning, that allows for the authentic use of literature and technology to enhance literary learning and foster 21st Century skills. (Laflan, 2013; Loera & Sinclair, 2019; Mills & Levido 2011; Smeda, Dakich & Sharda, 2014). Digital storytelling creation increases the engagement of students, through multiple learning styles and connects student’s interest with technology to desired learning and curriculum outcomes (Educause Learning Initiative, 2007; Mills & Levido 2011).

 

  • The TL will collaborate with the CT and SLSO to discuss the desired learning outcomes of creating a digital story, the technology to be used and the structure of groups of students. Students will work in groups of four with assigned roles to create their digital story using the Book Creator app for Ipads. Background information on the creation of digital stories and the features of Book Creator will be provided by the TL to the CT and SLSO.
  • The following texts and website will be available for students to choose from: Growing up Aboriginal in Australia (Heiss, 2019), Twelve Canoes (De Heer, & the Yolngu People of Ramingining, 2008), Young Dark Emu: A truer history (Pascoe, 2019). Students will use these texts as a basis for the creation of their digital story to meet the outcome of the struggle of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples for rights and freedoms before 1965, including the Stolen Generations (ACARA, 2010b).
  • In their group students will read and discuss their chosen text and establish a purpose for their story. Each student is assigned a specific role and responsibility; director, producer, writer, editor. This assists students in their own comprehension, understanding and perspectives of the text (Tobin, 2012).
  • Students are provided with instruction on the use of Book Creator and the importance of copyright, cultural sensitivity and the ethical use of music, pictures and video recordings; students will be encouraged to use Creative Commons to access media and will be shown the correct way to acknowledge sources used (State of NSW, 2020).
  • Once groups have completed their digital stories they will peer review two other groups’ digital stories; peer reviewing enhances students’ learning, promotes reflection, provides valuable feedback and creates positive learning environments (Jisc, 2015). Once feedback has been received students can review their work and make changes as required.
  • With students’ permission their digital stories will be uploaded to the school website and Facebook page to showcase the students’ understanding of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples struggle for rights and freedoms
  • For support and instructions of how digital storytelling can be implemented in the classroom view the following YouTube tutorial: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TE5DTD87-IE (Center for Innovative Learning Design at Fairmont Private Schools, 2014)
  • For further information related to the pedagogical benefits of digital storytelling read: Robin, B. (2008) Digital Storytelling: A Powerful Technology Tool for the 21st Century Classroom, Theory Into Practice, 47(3), 220-228, DOI: 10.1080/00405840802153916

 

 

 

Bibliography.

 

Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies and Pascoe, B. (2018). The little red yellow black book: an introduction to indigenous Australia. (4th ed.). Canberra, Australia: Aboriginal Studies Press.

 

De Heer, R. and the Yolngu People of Ramingining. (2008). Twelve canoes. Australia: Indigemedia Incorporated.

 

Heiss, A. (2020). Who Am I? [the diary of Mary Talence, Sydney, 1937]. Sydney, Australia: Omnibus Books.

 

Heiss, A. [Editor]. (2018). Growing up Aboriginal in Australia. Carlton, Australia: Black Inc.

 

Pascoe, B. (2019). Young dark emu: A truer history. Broome, Australia: Magalaba Books.

 

Roach, A. (2010). Took the children away. Australia: One Day Hill Publishers.

 

Vass, C. (2019). Sorry day. Canberra, Australia: National Library of Australia.

 

References

 

Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority (ACARAa) 2010, Critical and creative thinking. Retrieved from Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority website: https://www.australiancurriculum.edu.au/resources/curriculum-connections/portfolios/online-safety/

 

Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority (ACARAb) 2010, Year 10 content descriptions. Retrieved from Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority website: https://www.australiancurriculum.edu.au/f-10-curriculum/humanities-and-social-sciences/history/

 

Akins, M., Tichenor, M., Heins, E. & Piechura, K. (2018). Teachers’ knowledge of children’s literature: What genres do teachers read? Reading Improvement, 55(2), 63- 66. Retrieved from http://www.projectinnovation.com/reading-improvement.html

 

Collins, R. (2014).Skills for the 21st Century: teaching higher-order thinking. Curriculum & Leadership Journal, 12(14). Retrieved from http://www.curriculum.edu.au/leader/teaching_higher_order_thinking,37431.html?issueID=12910

 

 

Cornett, C. E. (2014). Integrating the literary arts throughout the curriculum. In Creating meaning through literature and the arts: Arts integration for classroom teachers (5th ed., pp. 144-193). Upper Saddle River: Prentice Hall.

Education Services Australia (2018). Schools Catalouge Information Service. Retrieved from https://my.scisdata.com/discover

 

Educause Learning Initiative. (2007). 7 things you should know about digital storytelling. Retrieved from https://library.educause.edu/resources/2007/1/7-things-you-should-know-about-digital-storytelling

 

Francis, J. (2017). The effects of technology on student motivation and engagement in classroom-based learning. Retrieved from https://dune.une.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1120&context=theses

 

Howell, J. (2014). Popularising History: Re-igniting pre-service teacher and student interest in history via historical fiction. Australian Journal of Teacher Education, 39(12). doi: 10.14221/ajte.2014v39n12.1

 

Jisc. (2015, October 9). Transforming assessment and feedback: peer review. Retrieved from https://www.jisc.ac.uk/guides/transforming-assessment-and-feedback/peer-review#

 

Laflen, A. (2013). Putting Wikis to Work in the Literature Classroom. Modern Language Studies, 43(1), 54-73. Retrieved from http://www.jstor.org/stable/24616720

 

Lamb, A., & Johnson, L. (2010). Divergent convergence part 2: Teaching and learning in a transmedia world. Teacher Librarian, 38(1), 64-69. Retrieved from https://ezproxy.csu.edu.au/login?url=https://search-proquest-com.ezproxy.csu.edu.au/docview/808408775?accountid=10344

 

Loera, M. & Sinclair, H. (2019). 5 reasons to integrate digital storytelling into your teaching. Retrieved from https://www.eschoolnews.com/2019/08/29/5-reasons-to-integrate-digital-storytelling-into-your-teaching/2/

 

Lorenz, T. (2019, October 19). High Schools to TikTok: We’re Catching Feelings. The New York Times. Retrieved from https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/19/style/high-school-tiktok-clubs.html

 

Sliwka, C. (2008). Connecting to history through historical fiction. Language arts journal of Michigan, 23(2). Retrieved from https://scholarworks.gvsu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1125&context=lajm

 

Mills, K. & Levido, A. (2011). iPed pedagogy for digital production. The Reading Teacher, 65(1), 80-91. doi: 10.1598/RT.65.1.11

 

Murdoch, K. (2015, October 26). Inspiring inquiry through picture books [Blog post]. Retrieved from https://www.kathmurdoch.com.au/blog/2015/10/26/bo3tpx8qkbkn6vwtemuj674amslke8

 

Pledger Consulting. (2020). ReadPlus. Retrieved from https://www.readplus.com.au/booksearch.php

 

Smeda, N., Dakich, E., & Sharda, N. (2014). The effectiveness of digital storytelling in the classrooms: a comprehensive study. Smart Learning Environments, 1(1). doi: 10.1186/s40561-014-0006-3

 

State of New South Wales [Department of Education]. (2020). Copyright and creative commons. Retrieved from https://www.digitalcitizenship.nsw.edu.au/articles/copyright-and-creative-commons

 

Tobin, M. (2012) Digital storytelling: Reinventing literature circles. Fischler College of Education: Faculty Articles. 1. Retrieved from https://nsuworks.nova.edu/fse_facarticles/1

 

 

 

Victoria State Government. (2019). Literacy teaching toolkit: multimodal literacy. Retrieved from https://www.education.vic.gov.au/school/teachers/teachingresources/discipline/english/literacy/readingviewing/Pages/litfocusmultimodal.aspx

 

Schwartzbach-Kang, A. & Kang, E. (2019). CSI Verona: Science and Literature Combine. Edutopia. Retrieved from

https://www.edutopia.org/article/csi-verona-science-and-literature-combine

 

Wyman, K. (2020). Why Teachers Need to Embrace Digital Storytelling. Resilient Educator. Retrieved from https://resilienteducator.com/classroom-resources/digital-storytelling/

 

 

Part B – Reflective Blog Post.

 

At the beginning of my ETL 402 journey, I will admit I had very little understanding of the difference between literacy learning and literary learning or the importance of selecting books to engage students in sustained enjoyable reading (Dunn, 2020a). This subject has allowed me to develop a very strong appreciation of the importance of literary learning across curriculum units to provide greater choices, to motivate students in their engagement with literacy and ultimately assisting students to learn ‘through’ literature. I noted it was important that educators are dealing with individuals who are reading in a vastly changed literature landscape and that the more ‘traditional’ reading of the past may not provide the same enjoyment and engagement with students of today (Dunn, 2020b).

 

I am now very excited to use the knowledge gained from assignment one to highlight the importance of various fiction collections within the library and how I can incorporated fiction into a variety of curriculum units. While assignment two has provided me with a greater understanding of the opportunities available to collaborate with classroom teachers and engage students with Literature Response Strategies within units of work. It is through our role as Teacher Librarians (TL) that we are able to provide relevant and engaging reading opportunities for students (Gibbons, 2020) as well as decreasing the anxiety of teachers of using technology with their classes; ultimately, through our role, we are able to bring new ideas about the use of technology and teaching strategies into the school (Dunn, 2020c).

 

I have already planned collaboratively with our HSIE faculty to implement the literary learning program, created for assignment two, with our Year 10 cohort when they are completing the depth study Rights and Freedoms 1945-present (ACARA, 2010) later this year. The students will be creating their own book bentos following the steps outlined in assignment two; this will involve collaboration between the HSIE faculty and myself. Collaboration will provide classroom teachers with a greater understanding of literary response strategies, use of historical fiction and non-fiction in the history classroom and the use of technology as a motivational and engagement strategy for students.

 

I am looking forward to spending more time developing further literary learning programs for our school and working collaboratively across curriculum areas to team teach units of work using a variety of literary response strategies. A large number of excellent examples of literary response strategies have been highlighted in our discussion forums (Murphy, 2020; Templeton, 2020). It has been an exciting journey discovering new aspects of children’s and young adult’s literature which I had a limited understanding of; applying literature to new learning experiences for students to engage and motivate reading at our school and ultimately create the bibliophiles of the future.

 

 

 

 

References

 

Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority (ACARA) 2010, Year 10 content descriptions. Retrieved from Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority website: https://www.australiancurriculum.edu.au/f-10-curriculum/humanities-and-social-sciences/history/

 

Dunn, B (2020a, March 20). Childrens literature [Blog post]. Retrieved from https://thinkspace.csu.edu.au/bellid/2020/03/20/childrens-literature/

 

Dunn, B (2020b, March 6). The changing of the book [Blog post]. Retrieved from https://thinkspace.csu.edu.au/bellid/2020/03/06/the-changing-of-the-book/

 

Dunn, B (2020c, April 29). Re: 4.2 Reading from the screen [Online discussion comment]. Retrieved from Charles Sturt University website: https://interact2.csu.edu.au/webapps/discussionboard/do/message?action=list_messages&course_id=_44234_1&nav=discussion_board_entry&conf_id=_88815_1&forum_id=_181938_1&message_id=_2862910_1

 

Gibbons, S (2020, May 2). Re: 4.2 Reading from the screen [Online discussion comment]. Retrieved from Charles Sturt University website: https://interact2.csu.edu.au/webapps/discussionboard/do/message?action=list_messages&course_id=_44234_1&nav=discussion_board_entry&conf_id=_88815_1&forum_id=_181938_1&message_id=_2862910_1

 

Murphy, D (2020, May 14).  6.3 Literature Circles in History [Online discussion comment]. Retrieved from Charles Sturt University website: https://interact2.csu.edu.au/webapps/discussionboard/do/message?action=list_messages&course_id=_44234_1&nav=discussion_board_entry&conf_id=_88815_1&forum_id=_181940_1&message_id=_2937474_1

 

Templeton, T. (2020, May 10). Book Trailers – [Online discussion comment]. Retrieved from Charles Sturt University website: https://interact2.csu.edu.au/webapps/discussionboard/do/message?action=list_messages&course_id=_44234_1&nav=discussion_board_entry&conf_id=_88815_1&forum_id=_181940_1&message_id=_2920970_1

 

 

 

Posted in ETL 402 | Tagged | Leave a comment

ETL402 – Assign 1

Graphic Novels – The Superheroes of the Library Collection.

 

Abstract

 

In the past, graphic novels were seen as the comic book character Robin of the fiction world, however, today graphic novels are now gaining their own spotlight as a popular genre in library collections and more importantly as a multimodal teaching strategy. In the High School setting graphic novels are now included as suggested texts for English by the NSW Board of Studies.

 

This article discusses the importance of the inclusion of graphic novels in the high school library. The article also considers the use of graphic novels as multimodal instructional examples and cross curricular learning aids through collaborative practices between the teacher librarian and classroom teachers.

 

Introduction

 

It is essential that school libraries support the diverse needs of the community through a well-resourced and managed space, providing material which promotes recreational reading has been shown to have cognitive and social benefits in addition to improved literacy outcomes (Rutherford et al. 2018).

Graphic novels are a form of multimodal literacy which supports students and provides engaging teaching strategy opportunities for students in Stages 4-6 through collaboration between the Teacher Librarian and classroom teachers. Graphic novels are often limited in school libraries or not successfully promoted to ensure engagement with students and staff.

 

Key Issues

 

Graphic novels have gained popularity with young adult readers since the late twentieth century and are now seen as an important inclusion in educational settings (Babee, 2017, p.1; Botzakis, 2018, p.140). Graphic novels have strong visual cues and multimodal features, this appeals to and motivates the learning of 21st Century students, as these individuals are constantly exposed to visual images in their daily lives through various automated formats (Gray, 2014, p.6; Short, 2018, p.289). The use of graphic novels in the educational setting has also been shown to motivate reluctant readers and students with low literacy due to the visual elements and contextual clues (IAPWE, 2019; Scholastic, 2018).

 

 

With the inclusion of graphic novels as recommended texts in the Australian Curriculum, it is paramount that educators include graphic novels in their teaching programs and that they are freely available for students to access in the school library. Graphic novels provide new teaching and learning opportunities for educators as they assist in the development of multi-literacies, due to their multimodal nature and provide students with the ability to make sense of an increasingly visual textual landscape which they are faced with during their daily lives (Laycock, 2019). It has been found that the selection of compulsory fiction texts can have a powerful impact on students’ attitudes and enjoyment of reading (Manuel & Carter, 2015. p.122). Graphic novels can be used to supplement and provide support for students that struggle with the compulsory reading of traditional longer text fiction books which are often used in Year 10 and 11 Advanced English.

 

The graphic novel adaptations of The Handmaid’s Tale (Nault, 2019) and To Kill a Mockingbird (Fordham, 2018) provide visual aids to supplement the written text which engages and empowers students and ultimately assists in their understanding of the concepts that are often difficult to grasp from the written text alone. Both graphic novels enable students to identify key concepts and analysis of characters through the use of highly evocative illustrations, framing, line, colour and facial expressions to provide students with an understanding of the text which they would not have been achieved through the written text alone.

 

Graphic novels can also support the cross curriculum priority areas of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander histories and cultures and Asia and Australia’s engagement with Asia in Stage 4 and 5 (ACARA, 2016). Ubby’s Underdogs: The legend of the phoenix dragon (McKenna, 2011) provides educators the opportunity to use the book to meet both cross curriculum priority areas; as it considers both Aboriginal and Chinese beliefs and cultures, as well as Australia’s connection and history with China. The book is written in a Japanese manga style that encourages readers through its style and storyline (Thomas, 2019). Webcomics and online graphic novels are becoming increasingly popular and provide a stimulating reading experience for students of the 21st Century; webcomics have been found to enhance comprehension, engagement and understanding (Ahamed & Harun, 2016, p.259). The Boat (Huynh, 2015) is an example of an online interactive graphic novel which uses technology to bring a story to life. The Boat (Huynh, 2015) immerses students with a rich story experience and an emotive understanding of the perils of refugees (Bowler et al 2012, p. 35) as well as considering the impact of War and Australia’s engagement with Asia. The Boat (Huynh, 2015) uses a range of techniques including limited colour, strong evocative sounds, songs, movement, drawings and photographs to evoke the struggle and fear faced by individuals and groups fleeing their homelands as refugees. The Boat (Huynh, 2015) could also be utilised as an example of multimodal text for Stage 6 English Standard school based assessment requirements (NESA, 2018, p. 6-7).

 

Graphic novels in the form of historical fiction are also an important addition to the curriculum and school library. White Bird (Palacio, 2019), whilst a work of fiction, is set in France during World War II and provides a deep understanding of the life and plight of Jewish people during the time period. This graphic novel would seamlessly fit into the Stage 5 History Curriculum and also Stage 6 Modern History. Historical fiction novels provide students with deeper, more meaningful topic exploration and allows students to consider the impact of events through the eyes of the characters in the novels (Rodwell, 2013), White Bird (Palacio, 2019) is a powerful example of this.

 

 

Value to Collection

 

Graphic novels are currently lacking in our library collection; this area needs resourcing with carefully selected texts that will engage patrons and be valuable resources for teachers to embed into curriculum programs. Graphic novels provide the opportunity for teachers to enhance the curriculum by either using a graphic novel adaptation of a current fiction novel used in class or using a graphic novel as a stand-alone teaching strategy. Graphic novels assist in expanding students’ understanding of key concepts and increases engagement with reading, while building on student’s multimodal knowledge and understanding by combining visual representations with text. (Beavis, 2013; Scott et al., 2017, p.127).

 

English Advanced classes in Year 10 can use the graphic adaptation of To Kill a Mockingbird (Fordham, 2018) and in Year 11 the graphic adaptation of The Handmaid’s Tale (Nault, 2019) to provide students with a greater understanding of what is often considered complex texts. Both graphic novels, while remaining true to the original story, improve comprehension of the novel and provide students with a greater appreciation and understanding of the key concepts and themes of the novels through visual representation (Chilton, 2018; Scott et al., 2017, p.127). To Kill a Mockingbird (Fordham, 2018) and The Handmaid’s Tale (Nault, 2019) are both significantly shorter than the original novels, however, through the emotive, graphic and outstandingly artistic imagery used within the graphic novels they both successfully convey the major plot lines and overall story of the text novels (Chilton, 2018 & Siwark, 2019). The outstanding art work in both of the novels assists readers throughout the stories; The Handmaid’s Tale’s (Nault, 2019) panels are vivid and immersive, with each hand painted watercolour illustration (Yarde, 2019) providing the reader a greater understanding of the characters and plot. While in To Kill a Mockingbird (Fordham, 2018) the artist uses limited colours with the drawings displaying an almost vintage feel (Lyons, nd), which transport the reader to the 1930’s Deep South.

 

By integrating graphic novels, teachers can enhance an existing curriculum and build on students’ multimodal knowledge as required in the Australian Curriculum. A number of graphic novels can also be used to meet Cross Curriculum Priorities. Ubby’s Underdogs: The legend of the phoenix dragon (McKenna, 2011) is an engaging novel for Stage 4 students and involves students in a manga style reading encompassing both Aboriginal and Chinese culture. The author of Ubby’s Underdogs: The legend of the phoenix dragon (McKenna, 2011) intertwines the long standing cultural relationship between Australia and China as well as providing an understanding of the traditional philosophy of both cultures (Thomas, 2019). The novel also considers Australia as a multicultural nation through the depth of characters introduced throughout the story. Ubby’s Underdogs: The legend of the phoenix dragon (McKenna, 2011) will assist readers who struggle with literacy, reluctant readers and English as a Second Language students as it provides an engaging storyline. The novel is easily accessible in its language and will assist in reading skill development through building vocabulary, visual literacy and is ultimately a less intimidating reading experience when compared to a traditional novel (Alverson, & Rycroft, 2014).

 

The Boat (Huynh, 2015), is an online interactive graphic novel adapted from Nam Le’s literary award winning anthology of the same name. The Boat (Huynh, 2015) provides the audience with a deep understanding of the perils of individuals who have to flee their homelands due to war or persecution. This novel will be used to assist with addressing the cross curriculum priority of Australia’s Engagement with Asia, as it explores a number of issues including  Australia’s involvement in the Vietnam War; as well as Vietnamese refugees seeking asylum in Australia during the 1970’s, which is brought to ‘vivid, harrowing life’ (Meares, 2015) unapologetically within this interactive graphic novel. The Boat (Huynh, 2015) delivers its story in a very different way to how it was originally written, viewers scroll through the story at their own pace with the text and images swaying and jolting in unison to the movement of the boat (George, 2015), which provides an immersive feeling of being a part of the story through sight and sound. Opportunities to further develop an empathetic and meaningful understanding of the struggles of refugees is provided through the use of side stories with archival photos and footage which delve into the character’s memories (George, 2015; Meares, 2015).

 

The inclusion of historical fiction into the library collection provides patrons with a deeper understanding and empathy of historical events than may not be achieved through the purely theory based study of events. Historical fiction novels can assist students to learn through making past events come to life in an often engaging and personal way (Diamond, 2017). White Bird (Palacio, 2019) successfully tells the story of the impacts of WWII on Jewish families living in occupied France and allows students to critically examine the events and history of WWII throughout the story (Scholastic, 2018). The book itself is broken into parts, with each part beginning with significant and relevant quotes from Muriel Rukeyser, Anne Frank and George Santayana, which provides readers with other significant writers of the time period (Daley, 2019). There is also a glossary, suggested reading list and bibliography at the end of the book which provides students with further avenues of study related to The Holocaust.

 

Role of the Teacher Librarian

 

The Teacher Librarian (TL) holds a pivotal role in the High School to develop, create and promote a library space and collection that encourages reading, creativity, inquiry and imagination (IFLA, 2015, p.25), while meeting the needs and desires of the patrons with engaging titles to promote not only reading for pleasure but also the inclusion of fiction into the curriculum. Hughes (2013) found that a contributing factor to students achieving their true potential was an adequately and consistently resourced school library; at this stage the school library is lacking in its collection of graphic novels. The TL must ensure that graphic novel titles are selected, organised, and presented using their professional and expert knowledge. The TL is responsible for curating the collection to ensure that they are selecting titles which will most benefit the patrons of the school library and meet the diverse needs of the school community.

 

It is essential that the TL manages the collection of graphic novels through acquisition, labelling, shelving and promotion of the novels. It is crucial that the graphic novel collection is shelved within its own area in the library (NLNZ, 2010), to ensure that the collection does not get lost within the fiction collection and to ensure that patrons are aware of the graphic novel collection. Creating displays at the entrance of the library that are eye-catching, colourful and encourage students to consider reading graphic novels is paramount when introducing graphic novels into the library to ensure that patrons are aware of the collection and motivated to engage with graphic novels (Suffield, 2019). The TL will also develop, write and publish materials (ASLA, 2016a, p.1) that will promote graphic novels through posters, the school newsletter and social media avenues such as the school’s Facebook and the library’s Instagram page, to ensure the wider school community has an understanding of the importance and value of including graphic novels into the library and to further motivate patrons to engage with the new area of the collection.

 

The TL, through their unique role has an in-depth knowledge of subjects and curriculum content through the completion of dual degrees in teaching and librarianship (ASLA, 2019). The TL is a curriculum leader and will utilise this knowledge to support and work openly and collaboratively with classroom teachers. Through collaboration the TL will work with classroom teachers, faculties and school curriculum committees (ASLA, 2019) to develop units of work, teaching strategies and activities that will incorporate the inclusion of graphic novels into subject areas. The TL will assist in the implementation of the units of work through team teaching within the well-resourced library spaces and evaluate the outcomes of the programs in consultation with faculties. This will ultimately create positive and productive learning environments that not only meet curriculum outcomes, but also engage students in reading; which ultimately assists in developing a culture of reading at the school. (AITSL, 2018, p.8; ASLA, 2016b, p.1). The provision and promotion of high quality graphic novels by the TL within the school library will develop and support student’s pleasure for reading and ultimately create connections and improve student outcomes through enriching student’s intellectual, cultural and emotional growth (NLNZ, 2020; Rashidah, 2017).

 

 

Conclusion

 

Inclusion of graphic novels into the school library collection will lead to positive learning experiences and increased motivation for recreational reading for the patrons of the school library. The graphic novels provide 21st Century students the opportunity to be exposed to a variety of multimodal styles to assist in their knowledge and understanding across a number of curriculum areas.

 

 

 

 

Bibliography of Literature

 

Fordham, F. (2018). To kill a mockingbird: a graphic novel. London: Penguin Random House.

 

Huynh, M. (2015). The boat. SBS Australia. Retrieved from http://www.sbs.com.au/theboat/

 

McKenna, B. (2011). Ubby’s underdogs: the legend of the phoenix dragon. Broome: Magabala Books

 

Nault, R. (2019). The handmaid’s tale: the graphic novel. London: Penguin Random House.

 

Palacio, R. (2019). White bird. London: Penguin Random House.

.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

References

 

Ahamed, A., & Harun, R. (2016). The Principles Adopted In Designing the Webcomics to Assist Lower Secondary Students with Reading Comprehension. International Journal of Research in Business and Social Sciences, 6(11). (pp. 255-260). doi: 10.6007/ijarbss/v6-i11/2458

Alverson, B. (2014, September 08). [Blog Post]. Teaching With Graphic Novels. School Library Journal. Retrieved from https://www.slj.com/?detailStory=the-graphic-advantage-teaching-with-graphic-novels

Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority [ACARA]. (2016). Cross-curriculum priorities. Retrieved from https://www.acara.edu.au/curriculum/foundation-year-10/cross-curriculum-priorities

 

Australian Institute for Teaching and School Leadership [AITSL]. (2018). Australian professional standards for teachers. Retrieved from https://www.aitsl.edu.au/docs/default-source/national-policy-framework/australian-professional-standards-for-teachers.pdf?sfvrsn=5800f33c_64

 

Australian School Library Association [ASLA]. (2019). What is a teacher librarian. Retrieved from https://asla.org.au/what-is-a-teacher-librarian

 

Australian School Library Association [ASLA]. (2016a). Statement on Library and Information Services in Schools. Retrieved from https://asla.org.au/resources/Documents/Website%20Documents/Policies/policy_Library_Information_Services.pdf

 

Australian School Library Association [ASLA]. (2016b).Statement on teacher librarians in Australia. Retrieved from https://asla.org.au/resources/Documents/Website%20Documents/Policies/policy_tls_in_australia.pdf

 

Babaee, R. (2017). Realities of Graphic Novels: An Interview with Frederick Aldama. International Journal of Comparative Literature and Translation Studies, 5(3), (pp. 1-4). doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.7575/aiac.ijclts.v.5n.3p.1

 

Beavis, C. (2013, June 23). Teaching graphic novels as literature: The complete Maus enters the curriculum. [Blog post]. Retrieved from https://theconversation.com/teaching-graphic-novels-as-literature-the-complete-maus-enters-the-curriculum-13852

Botzakis, S. (2018). Comics in the Classroom. In Wooten, D. A., Liang, L. A., & Cullinan, B. E. (Eds.). Children’s literature in the reading program, fifth edition: Engaging young readers in the 21st century. (pp. 140-152). Retrieved from https://ebookcentral.proquest.com

 

Bowler, L., Morris, R., Cheng, I., AlIssa, R., Romine, B., & Leiberling, L. (2012). Multimodal stories: LIS students explore reading, literacy, and library service through the lens of the 39 clues. Journal of Education for Library and Information Science, 53(1), 32-48. Retrieved from https://www.jstor.org/stable/23249095

Chilton, M. (2018, October 27). The rise of graphic novels, from Sabrina to To Kill a Mockingbird. The Independent. Retrieved from https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/books/features/sabrina-graphic-novels-booker-prize-to-kill-a-mocking-bird-a8604136.html

 

Daley, M. (2019, October 9). Review of White Bird. Children’s books daily. Retrieved from https://childrensbooksdaily.com/book_reviews/review-of-white-bird/

 

Diamond, A. (2017, February 21). Using Historical Fiction to Connect Past and Present. The Atlantic. Retrieved from https://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2017/02/using-historical-fiction-to-connect-past-and-present/516543/

 

George, S. (2015, April 29). The sound and vision of The Boat. SBS. Retrieved from https://www.sbs.com.au/movies/article/2015/04/27/sound-and-vision-boat

 

Gray, K. (2014). Graphic novels: providing a different perspective. Connections, (91), 6-7. Retrieved from https://www.scisdata.com/connections/issue-91/graphic-novels-providing-a-different-perspective

 

Hughes, H. (2013). School libraries and teacher-librarians: evidence of their contribution to student literacy and learning. Curriculum & Leadership Journal, 11(12). Retrieved from http://www.curriculum.edu.au/leader/school_libraries_and_tls,36453.html?issueID=12777

International Association of Professional Writers and Editors [IAPWE]. (2019).Graphic Novels Are Gaining in Popularity. Retrieved from https://iapwe.org/graphic-novels-are-gaining-in-popularity/

International Federation of Library Associations and Institutions [IFLA]. (2015). IFLA school library guidelines. Retrieved from: https://www.ifla.org/files/assets/school-libraries-resource-centers/publications/ifla-school-library-guidelines.pdf

 

Laycock, D. (2019). Pilgrims in a foreign land: Teachers using graphic novels as classroom texts. Scan 38(2). Retrieved from https://search.informit.com.au/documentSummary;dn=904766889735342;res=IELHSS

 

Lyons, C. (nd). To Kill a Mocking Bird (Fordham, 2018) a graphic novel. New Journal of Books. Retrieved from https://www.nyjournalofbooks.com/book-review/kill-mockingbird

 

Manuel, J. & Carter, D. (2015). Current and historical perspectives on Australian teenagers’ reading practices and preferences [online]. The Australian Journal of Language and Literacy, 38(2), 115-128. Retrieved from <https://search.informit.com.au/documentSummary;dn=209867285696838;res=IELAPA>

 

Meares, J. (2015, April 28). SBS’s interactive graphic novel The Boat brings Vietnamese refugee experience to life. The Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved from https://www.smh.com.au/entertainment/books/sbss-interactive-graphic-novel-the-boat-brings-vietnamese-refugee-experience-to-life-20150428-1muwo7.html

National Library of New Zealand. [NLNZ]. (2020). Why school libraries matter. Retrieved from https://natlib.govt.nz/schools/school-libraries/understanding-school-libraries/why-school-libraries-matter

National Library of New Zealand. [NLNZ]. (2010). Graphic novels. Retrieved from https://natlib.govt.nz/schools/reading-engagement/childrens-and-youth-literature/graphic-novels

 

NSW Education Standards Authority. [NESA]. (2018). English standard stage 6 syllabus. Retrieved from NSW Education Standards Authority website: https://educationstandards.nsw.edu.au/wps/portal/nesa/11-12/stage-6-learning-areas/stage-6-english/english-standard-2017

 

Rashidah. (2017, August 24). The Importance of school library and knowledge SAFSMS Blog. Retrieved from https://safsms.com/blog/importance-academic-library-schools/

 

Rodwell, G. (2013). Understanding the Past through Historical Fiction. In Whose History?: Engaging History Students through Historical Fiction 151-170. South Australia: University of Adelaide Press. Retrieved from www.jstor.org/stable/10.20851/j.ctt1t304sf.16

Rutherford, L., Merga, M., and Singleton, A. (2018). Influences on Australian adolescents’ recreational reading. The Australian Journal of Language and Literacy, 41(1), 44-56. Retrieved from https://search.informit.com.au/documentSummary;dn=321113384699281;res=IELHSS

Rycroft, K. (2014). Graphic Novels: Preparing for a Mulitmodal and Multiliterate World. Inquiries Journal/Student Pulse, 6(8). Retrieved from http://www.inquiriesjournal.com/a?id=907

 

Scott. C, Taylor. C, Buhlman. B, Dunne. A, Garmon. C, Lopez. N & Miles. A. (2017). Review of WHAM! Teaching with Graphic Novels Across the Curriculum. Journal of Language and Literacy Education 13(1) 125-130. Retrieved from https://www.researchgate.net/publication/321171237_Review_of_WHAM_Teaching_with_Graphic_Novels_Across_the_Curriculum

 

Scholastic (2018). A guide to using graphic novels with children and teens. Retrieved from https://www.scholastic.com/content/dam/teachers/lesson-plans/18-19/Graphic-Novel-Discussion-Guide-2018.pdf

 

Short, K. G. (2018). What’s trending in children’s literature and why it matters. Language Arts, 95(5), 287-298. Retrieved from https://search-proquest-com.ezproxy.csu.edu.au/docview/2036727382?accountid=10344

 

Siwak, M. (2019, April 9). Graphic novel illustrations bring reverence to ‘Handmaid’s Tale’. The Pop Insider. Retrieved from https://thepopinsider.com/reviews/books/the-handmaids-tale-graphic-novel-review/

 

Suffield, E. (2019). Promoting reading for pleasure in school libraries. School Catalogue Information Service, 108(1), 1-3. Retrieved from https://www.scisdata.com/media/1806/connections108.pdf

 

Thomas, J. (2019). Ubby’s underdogs, a new vision for Australia and the future of English teaching [online]. English in Australia, 54(1), 53-58. Retrieved from <https://search.informit.com.au/documentSummary;dn=679196140149235;res=IELIAC>

 

Yarde, A. (2019, March 26). Book Review: The Handmaid’s Tale (The Graphic Novel) by Margaret Atwood *Art & Adaptation by Renee Nault Nan A. Tales / Doubleday. The Good Men Project. Retrieved from https://goodmenproject.com/featured-content/456808-xela/

 

Posted in ETL 402 | Tagged | Leave a comment

Children’s Literature.

At its most basic children’s literature is any form of literature that has been written with the intended audience of children in mind. Within this classification there are inevitably various groupings including books for babies, young children, middle grade and young adults. My knowledge of Children’s literature at this stage could be considered somewhat lacking with only a small exposure to what children like and enjoy reading – I am hoping this unit will assist in my learning journey to be better equipped to select and suggest targeted literature to high school students and teachers in order to assist in creating lifelong readers.

 

Some strategies I am currently using to increase my professional knowledge include:

  • Young Adult section on Goodreads
  • LoveOzYa
  • Australian Standing Orders
  • Various Facebook groups such as Your Kids Next Read
  • Reading Blogs such as the Bottom Shelf by Barbara Branxton
  • Articles related to children’s reading and literature.
Posted in ETL 402 | Tagged | Leave a comment

The Changing of the Book.

Ferguson, D. (2020). in her article states that ‘children today are reading less and finding less enjoyment from reading than in previous generations’, this is a contradiction to author Khyiah Angel (as cited in Taylor, 2018) where she found ‘that children are reading more, they are just reading differently’. It is important to note though that we are dealing with individuals who are reading in a vastly changed literature landscape and that the more ‘traditional’ reading of the past may not provide the same enjoyment and engagement with students of today.  Students have early access to mobile devices and the internet in their everyday lives and are often termed ‘digital natives’ due to the high exposure to digital technology in their lives (Helsper & Eynon, 2010, p.503). The children’s book market is adapting to meet the demands within the childrens and young adult categories of literature and providing young people with a greater range and innovation than ever before. Audio and Ebooks provide the opportunity to have access to reading material at any point in time and the formats can be adapted to meet the reading style of the individual to ensure the greatest level of accessibility, engagement and enjoyment. As Short (2018), highlights visual imagery is an important facet in the children’s book market due to the changing nature of the audience and that images assist in students making meaning from reading material. Authors are also changing their style of delivery of reading material, with a standout being ‘I know why you run’ by Khyiah Angel where a traditional print book incorporates technology through the use of augmented reality – allowing the reader to be immersed in the story and to also create their own plots as part of the reading experience. The future will continue to see an adaptation of the traditional book to meet the changing preferences of children and young adults and to ensure they have greater access to books in various formats which engage and excite the reader. 

References

Angel, K. (2018). I know why you run. [mbook]. Australia: Typology Tech.

Ferguson, D. (2020, February 29). Children are reading less than ever before, research reveals. The Guardian. Retrieved from https://www.theguardian.com/education/2020/feb/29/children-reading-less-says-new-research

Helsper, E., & Eynon, R. (2010). Digital natives: Where is the evidence? British Educational Research Journal, 36(3), 503-520. Retrieved from http://www.jstor.org/stable/27823621

Short, K. (2018). What’s trending in children’s literature and why it matters. Language Arts, 95(5), 287- 298. Retrieved from https://search-proquest-com.ezproxy.csu.edu.au/docview/2036727382/fulltextPDF/A6666AC515B942C1PQ/1?accountid=10344

Taylor, A. (2018, September 16). ‘Technology can bring books alive’: Harry Potter inspires novel with moving images. The Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved from https://www.smh.com.au/entertainment/books/technology-can-bring-books-alive-harry-potter-inspires-novel-with-moving-images-20180915-p50407.html

Posted in ETL 402 | Tagged | Leave a comment