data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1b663/1b66318313e00a6e4d1e883aa5aa9216b2fc11aa" alt="Photo by LinkedIn Sales Solutions on Unsplash"
The difference between a proficient and highly accomplished teacher librarian
What separates a proficient teacher librarian from a highly accomplished one? By analysing the Australian School Library Association’s Evidence Guides and the Australian Professional Standards for Teachers (Australian Institute for Teaching and School Leadership, 2011), one can identify the skills and qualities that set highly proficient teacher librarians apart from those who are proficient. This blog post will use teaching standard 3.4 Select and use resources to compare and contrast.
As all my experience has been centred around classroom teaching, I currently do not have any practical experience within the school library. However, when looking at teaching standard 3.4 in the ASLA Evidence Guide for teacher librarians in the proficient career stage (Australian School Library Association, 2014b), I can see parallels between skills that I have developed in the classroom and those that are implemented by a proficient teacher librarian. For instance, the first example of evidence states: “unit of work, lesson plan or learning activity that involved students’ use of digital resources” (Australian School Library Association, 2014b, p.10). I have experience planning, sharing, and implementing a junior primary Unit of Inquiry on coding using apps on iPads. When undertaking the role of a teacher librarian in the future, I will be able to transfer across some of my skills developed in the classroom. However, once in the role I need to know where to go to further develop my skills and become a highly accomplished teacher librarian.
The first place to look for this information is the ASLA Evidence Guides for Teacher Librarians. Below are screenshots of teaching standard 3.4 from the Evidence Guide for teacher librarians in the highly accomplished career stage (Australian School Library Association, 2014a) and the Evidence Guide for teacher librarians in the proficient career stage (Australian School Library Association, 2014b):
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/072b7/072b7c63d700a010a2889ac9cdb065038c1327ff" alt="An extract from the Evidence Guide for Teacher Librarians in The Highly Accomplished Career Stage (Australian School Library Association, 2014, p. 11)."
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/05175/05175c4a5d7df1f0e9558b81742e9ece0aafe032" alt="An extract from the Evidence Guide for Teacher Librarians in The Highly Accomplished Career Stage (Australian School Library Association, 2014, p. 11)."
When comparing the two Evidence Guides, there is one quality that is weaved throughout the examples given for a ‘highly accomplished’ teacher librarian that is missing from the ‘proficient’ teacher librarian examples. That quality is: collaboration. The proficient teacher librarian is undertaking tasks crucial to their role, but the involvement of other stakeholders in the processes appear limited. The highly accomplished teacher librarian builds upon this by engaging others within the school community. This is evidenced by the many collaborative verbs included within the example, such as ‘assist’, ‘co-operate’, ‘recommend’, ‘share’, ‘demonstrate’. It also highlights the different stakeholders in which they are collaborating with, such as staff, colleagues, and professional networks. They essentially become the information expert that guides their school community in the resourcing of the curriculum.
Collaboration is also the key focus from teaching standard 3.4’s ‘illustration of practice’ video entitled Selecting Resources (Australian Institute for Teaching and School Leadership, 2016). The video interviews Teacher Librarian Anne Chowne, who gives us a glimpse into how she collaborates with a wide range of staff, such as planning with a fellow teacher librarian and consulting with the director of teaching and learning. She also describes how she collaborates with teaching staff in the development of the collection; showing teachers what is available in the library and filling in resourcing gaps.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/44907/449071ce61ec0e772431efe1f3c449d9a4ec7d33" alt="Teacher Librarian Anne Chowne collaborates with the director of teaching and learning (Australian Institute for Teaching and School Leadership, 2016)."
The significance of collaboration in the success of the school library is backed by Hughes-Hassell and Mancall (2005, p.66), who state that “collaboration is the key concept underlying the development of learner-centred collections and collection services”. Creating a collaborative culture as a teacher librarian is no easy feat, as I have reflected on in a previous blog post, but for a school library collection to remain relevant and reflect the needs of its learning community, it is essential that the teacher librarian develops and maintains a culture of collaboration within their school community.
So, what does this mean for me as a future teacher librarian? From analysing the Australian School Library Association’s Evidence Guides (2014a, 2014b) and the Australian Professional Standards for Teachers (Australian Institute for Teaching and School Leadership, 2011) it is clear that developing strong relationships with those I will work with within the school community is essential to become a highly accomplished teacher librarian. I will also need to seek out, join and be an active participant in professional networks in the broader community. Prioritising collaboration should ensure that I am able to provide my future school community with a 21st century library that meets the needs of the teachers and learners within it.
References:
Australian Institute for Teaching and School Leadership. (2011). Australian Professional Standards for Teachers. AITSL. https://www.aitsl.edu.au/teach/standards
Australian Institute for Teaching and School Leadership. (2016, April). Selecting resources
. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JYGyYV8AxPU&t=280s
Australian School Library Association. (2014a). Evidence Guide for Teacher Librarians in The Highly Accomplished Career Stage. ASLA. https://asla.org.au/evidence-guides-tls
Australian School Library Association. (2014b). Evidence Guide for Teacher Librarians in The Proficient Career Stage. ASLA. https://asla.org.au/evidence-guides-tls
Hughes-Hassell, S. & Mancall, J. (2005). Collection management for youth: Responding to the needs of learners. ALA Editions.