Bloom, Fink and going SOLO in a BYOD world

Taxonomy of learning in knowledge networks

inmap (1)

A map of my LinkedIn Professional Learning Network

Taxonomies

I am science trained and know that in the study of the sciences, taxonomies are not set in stone. The way we classify organisms  has changed since I was a Biology student. Back then we also had nine planets in our Solar System, whereas now we have eight because the way we categorise planets has changed. These changes are a great lesson in how knowledge changes over time. Our world views change.

I am keeping this in mind as I explore the learning taxonomies that have played a major role in education, including those shown below in Figure 1.

Are these taxonomies relevant in 21st Century classrooms?

What is a learning taxonomy anyway? According to O’Neill (2010): “Learning
 taxonomies
 or
 classifications
 are commonly
 utilised
 as
 a
 way
 of
 describing
 observable
 learning
 behaviours
 and
 activities
 that
 we
 wish
 our
 students
 to
 develop.” The following image (Figure 1) shows some Taxonomies along with their dates of publication.

taxonomy

Figure 1 : Educational Taxonomies : Sourced from O’Neill & Murphy (2010)

These taxonomies have assisted many educators in describing student learning. So whilst engaging with Bloom’s Revised Taxonomy (Anderson 2001) we learn to describe student learning in terms of listing, memorising, reciting, classifying, reading, rewriting, finding…to perhaps show they have stored prescribed knowledge in their heads. For your interest read Biggs and Collis (1982) to help develop an understanding of SOLO.

However, educators such as Steve Wheeler (2012) are now making sense of new world views where knowledge is more widely distributed and sits outside of the learner. As Weinberger (2011) says: “Our skulls and our institutions are simply not big enough to contain knowledge. Knowledge is now a property of the network….”

Should we, in light of the connected world we now live in and the knowledge networks that our students can draw on change the  ways we view and describe student behaviour and learning outcomes.  After all, we are now just a node amongst many. Things have changed. The information ecology that we now exist in has changed.

Just for interest, the social graph at the top of this post illustrates my LinkedIn network. This can be seen as a good example of a knowledge network.

Another observation is that these taxonomies describe the individual and do not reflect a connected digital world where learning is becoming “increasingly a networked phenomenon”. (O’Connell 2014)

Connectivism

Educators are now discussing connectivism (Siemens, 2004) which is proving to be a good lens through which to explore 21st Century Learning. Louise Starkey (2010) does this with clarity.  She argues that 21st century educators will be “limited in their ability to teach the upcoming generation to be active participants in a digitally enhanced society without understanding how to apply theories of learning that are relevant to a digital age into their practice.”

As a simple activity, try Googling “Bloom’s Digital Taxonomy’ using Google images. The colourful search result that appears on my screen suggests that we are struggling to  fit an old tool to a new purpose. Maybe also, we are trying to fit new digital tools into old taxonomies. Steve Wheeler (2012 June 26) talks of “Bloom reheated”. What are your thoughts on this?

As explored by Bawden (2012) “technology does not change the ways of dealing with information” but information ecologies have changed particularly with the advent of social media technologies. In this new information ecology, should we continue to refer to Bloom’s (revised) taxonomy whilst reflecting on lesson plans and pedagogy. Or should we, you perhaps, refer to a new tool through which you would reflect on your teaching?

Computational thinking might provide new guiding language/taxonomies.

Starkey (2011) argues that the connections that a student makes are an  important part of learning in the digital age and “it is through these connections that knowledge is created and critiqued”. This is an extremely important concept that is well worth exploring, particularly if we want to taxonomise such learning while acknowledging collaboration, connections, creation of knowledge and the sharing of this knowledge.

Summary

Alongside a group of CSU students scattered through Australia and overseas, I am currently learning to:

  • think critically
  • learn through connections
  • create and share knowledge

Some of the knowledge we are aggregating, curating, tagging, creating and critiquing is shared knowledge as it is stored in and accessible via our knowledge networks. How would Bloom, Fink and Biggs have structured their learning taxonomies to describe the learning that I am participating in?

References:

Bawden, D. & Robinson, l. (2012). Information behaviour. In Introduction to information science (pp. 187 – 210). London: facet.

Biggs, J. B. and Collis, K. (1982) Evaluating the Quality of Learning: the SOLO taxonomy. New York, Academic Press

O’Neill, G. and Murphy, F. (2010) Guide to Taxonomies of Learning. Retrieved from UCD website http://www.ucd.ie/t4cms/ucdtla0034.pdf

O’Connell, S. (2014) Knowledge Networks – Connected communities, open access, and connected learning [INF530 Module 3]. Retrieved March 29, 2014 from Charles Sturt University website: http://digital.csu.edu.au/inf530/module-3-knowledge-networks-connected-communities-open-access-and-connected-learning/

Weinberger, D. (2011) Too Big To Know. New York. Basic Books

Wheeler, S. (2012 June 26) Bloom reheated. [Web log] Steve Wheeler Blogspot. Retrieved from http://steve-wheeler.blogspot.com.au/2012/06/bloom-reheated.html

Wheeler, S. (2012 Oct 26th) Theories for the digital age: Connectivism. [Web log] Steve Wheeler Blogspot. Retrieved from http://steve-wheeler.blogspot.com.au/2012/10/theories-for-digital-age-connectivism.html

 

Bookmark and Share
110 Comments
  1. I love your finishing question Simon. You raise some interesting considerations that appeal to me, The image growing in my mind as a result of our course is The Great Dividing Range – what I observe in classrooms and what I have seen in effectively integrated ICT learning environments is so separate. Taxonomies like Blooms still seem to indicate that a teacher is a separate entity from the learners. I believe teachers a critical to the process but not in the old hierarchical manner that still reigns in so many classrooms.

  2. This is really interesting to think about Blooms as separating the teacher from the students – I’d never seen it that way before but it does seem to fit now it’s been pointed out. Going to go and read Bloom reheated now…

  3. Let me know what your reaction was to that article Matt.
    Blooms does help me to describe some of my kids learning but I am not sure it a tool that should be used to direct pedagogy.

    • Hmm, I’m not sure there is much to go on here. It’s clear that Blooms requires a relook and that Anderson’s revised model may not have gone far enough but this article seems to be only really pointing that out and not going much further.

      What I have found interesting though is in the comments below the references to whether Connectivism can be classed as a theory – “many argue it is too ill-defined and not really a theory.”

      This has led me down another ‘rabbit hole’ into the discussions around this. Have a look at this (I’m only half way through but it’s an interesting read):
      http://www.irrodl.org/index.php/irrodl/article/viewArticle/523/1103%22

  4. A great post..one to go on global record as a great example of a student thrashing out ideas as he engages with his network. What you highlight for me is not only the evolving nature of the theories and constructs, but the urgent need to research the emerging context/s. It’s all very well to just revise and present a new ‘take’ on a model such as Blooms (we see this all the time in graphics related to ipad apps as an example). But twisting and turning ideas also needs deep investigation and evidence of the changes. I long to see more work in this area – and maybe graduates of this course will one day be lead researchers in this field! Steve Wheeler is a great catalyst for thinking – love his work too. Information behaviour and cognitive engagement in new digital environments – what models do we really need? New or transformed? I don’t know the answer.

  5. You are right Matt. There is not a lot to go on there [ Wheeler, S. (2012 June 26)] but I read this within the context of writing the above post so it made me think I wasn’t going down a silly path in my meanderings. I, like the way Wheeler writes. Uncomplicated and to the point…thus all he wanted to say was that perhaps Bloom’s taxonomy had seen it days.
    Thanks for the link. i think I saw this paper in my wanderings but will have another think on it. Do let me know what you get out of it.

  6. Hi Simon,

    Thanks for your analysis of taxonomies of learning in knowledge networks. I notice that the linkedIn Professional Learning Network is a great way to represent this idea visually for readers to get a quick grasp of the complicated nature of things. You have also included the O’Neill and Murphy diagram that helped to demonstrate more about the history of taxonomies and their development too. It is difficult to predict the result of recent changes in digital learning environments on the implementation of taxonomies that are used in such class rooms. One possible example is that of assessment marking criteria that often structure the wording of awarded marks in de/ ascending order according to associated knowledge and or skills from Bloom’s taxonomy. It was great to read Wheeler’s blogs. The information is written well.
    An important aspect of the need to develop taxonomies properly was evident in O’Neill and Murphy (2010) where they describe the taxonomies in their University College of Dublin as being ‘affective’ and that subsequently an expected outcome of college graduates from the University is that they are able to respond to the world with a highly developed value system. If curricula is to develop in the right direction for the future then the stakeholders must consider digital learners not only as part of a network but as human beings with personal, cultural and social values and ideas.
    An important area of recent radical development that can hopefully assist with the importance of getting taxonomies right is the Neurosciences. Psychologists are using Neurobiology to understand the brain and how it works. Taxonomies are some ways quite similar to the brain in the way that certain functions are scaffolded. A good example of this is the area of the brain that relates to literacy. The Broca and Wernicke reading areas both need to be developed before the writing area in the parietal lobe can ‘click into place’ and start writing. Hopefully the balance between developing new knowledge and skills efficiently can be achieved while also providing an affective structure for social values and ideas.
    After searching google images for Blooms digital taxonomy it was clear that there are an increasing range of new contexts for learning processes to live with. It was interesting to see how some people categorise certain ‘Apps’ into the hierarchy of Bloom’s Taxonomy. It was a new and useful way to view Apps in relation to their implementation in certain learning activities, thanks. Ben Williamson has outlined a range of important social aspects related to the marketing of digital education resources in ‘The Future of the Curriculum’. It is well worth a read. Good luck.

  7. Receive Online Database Management Assignment Help from experts of Abc Assignment Help. Our online team hold good experience in providing quality Database Management Help with utmost accuracy. Our Database Management team is professional to handle any questions. We provide answers on topics of Data Mining, Data Analytic, Object Oriented and more. For instant solution get in touch with our online professionals.
    https://www.abcassignmenthelp.com/database-management-assignment-help

  8. If you are looking for Essay help services then hire our experts essay writer. We have many years of experience in the same field. You can contact here:- +353 12544925

  9. office.com/setup
    – MS Office provides a wide range of programs that are used to customize and create various dynamic documents, spreadsheets, presentations, and other business tasks. The application is developed by Microsoft and is used in various Offices and institutions.

  10. Assignment Writing Help for singapore students is available in the lowest cost by Singapore expert writers of SingaporeAssignmentHelp.com. We is now offering the best assignment help services using the best quality content at cheap price. To avail these services contact our Assignment writing expert

  11. On a daily basis, millions of users are trying to use the wireless printing technology. Wireless printing technology gives the permission to the users to print the documents wirelessly. This technology makes each user comfortable, trouble-free and quick. I want to use the wireless printing technology. I want to establish the wireless connection on my printer. I don’t have much experience to set up the wireless connection on my printer with the help of WPS PIN code. I am failing to set up the wireless connection on my printing machine. So anyone can share the easy tips to set up wireless connection on my printer with the help of WPS pin code

  12. What will happen if Cash app transfer failed?
    Cash app regularly monitors your account to look for if there is any ordinary activity. If anything happened there or Cash app transfer failed, then your funds will be immediately refunded on the original source of payment after completing the investigation. If you have any issues, then feel free to contact us. ​https://www.emailcontacthelp.com/blog/cash-app-transfer-failed/

  13. We are a full and trained technical guide, having immense years of experience and proficiency of offering the best technical support services for online users. If you want to set up canon mg 3600 printer and don’t have solutions to set up your printer, you can get connected with live technical experts to complete the set up procedure of Canon MG3600 Wireless Set-Up in the proper ways. Our online technical experts have the great skills and extensive experience for canon mg 3600 set up procedure in the proper ways. Our online technical team is ready to assist you for any type of technical issues.
    https://www.canonprintersupportpro.us/blog/canon-pixma-mg3600-setup/

  14. The taxonomy of learning in knowledge networks means to classify learning objects, assessments, and activities in a clear and concise manner. Taxonomy simply means the classification of structures. This knowledge is to produce students that will be able to actively participate in society. UK Assignment Help | AssignmentCorner.co.uk

  15. Accounting assignment help allows you to connect with experts and get effective assistance for your project submission. Don’t forget to check out all the features before buying the services of online assignment help for your accounting papers.

  16. The latest version of the Microsoft Office has been a pioneering breakthrough along the past couple of decades, Office saw some substantial updates with the accession of new features every time, and the latest Office version available today is the Office 2019, which can be downloaded from office.com/setup and also the latest version has eight alternatives popularity
    popularity

  17. If you want your HP printer only use black ink then you can easily change in the settings to print with black ink only, But there can be different steps depending upon the different model printer models. All the steps are mentioned in our blog How do I get my hp printer to only use black ink. Follow the steps and yur problem will be solved.

  18. Sometimes spectrum wifi password change can be a task. If you want to change the password you need to feel tsome steps. First of all you need to find a pre-set password than only you will be able to change it. To reset the password first sign in to your account, if you don’t have an account create a new account. select the option saying “internet” available under the “Services” section. it will display the network’s name, change them click on the update option and save the settings.
    https://how-to-reset.com/blog/change-wifi-password-spectrum/
    spectrum wifi password change

  19. Canon printer in error state – If Canon printer not being able to print at a critical time is given below: The print jobs are stuck in the printer queue. Paper jams disable the printer’s ability to print. Faulty drivers or wireless connections do not allow the printer to print.
    1. Check canon printer error message.
    2. Check driver setting menu
    3. Chch connectivity between computer and printer properly.
    4. Check Wire, Cables connection
    5. Reset or on-off Machine
    https://canon-printer-support-numbers.com/canon-printer-in-error-state/

  20. My assignment help services online available from our inhouse team of experienced writers can help you raise your grades. We offer adept writing assistance in various subjects like management, statistics, psychology, nursing, computer science, law and engineering. Our assignment helpers are well versed with your university guidelines and ensure that every paper you’re your professor’s expectations in terms of plagiarism free quality work and timely submission.

  21. Incapable to send money from Paypal to Cash App because of web? Call help group
    In the event that you neglected to send money from Paypal to Cash App because of poor net association, at that point you connect with the help locales that are offering compelling answers for help you out with the issue. Notwithstanding that, you can utilize the arrangements that are made accessible by the client care administration.
    https://www.gonetech.net/process-to-send-money-from-paypal-to-cash-app/

  22. If you computer is not opening properly or you are facing hardware related issues then you need to reset Bios settings in order to diagnose the other hardware related issues and to perform a reset bios password process the moment you are facing trouble in booting up your device.

  23. Myassignmenthelperonline.com is the right address where you can get quickly honest and the best student homework help services according to necessities. We have more than 5000 Ph.D. specialists who provide the best online study material to the students who ask for homework help from us.

  24. Students must avail of professional Online Homework Doer service if they want to hire someone to do my homework cheap. Grab assignment help services to boost your knowledge and get high marks in your exams. Well if you get the time you can contact Allassignmenthelp.com.

  25. Clara Smith is an English professor working at a reputed college in Australia. She provides
    essay writing help to students via allessaywriter.com on request. During her free time, clara likes to watch movies, read books, and play Pokemon Go.

  26. Get Best Quality Online Assignment Help Sydney Service from New Assignment Help. we are the most Affordable Essay Writing Service in Sydney. Best Price, Plagiarism Free work,Guaranteed better Grades,On Time Delivery.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *